I have researched this myself and created a similar post in the holy huddle room. But I open it up for general discussion.
1) What exactly must be done to be saved?
2) What is the criteria used by God to determine judgement?
3) Who will be saved?
4) Who will NOT be saved?
Criteria for salvation; what must we do?
Moderator: Moderators
- achilles12604
- Site Supporter
- Posts: 3697
- Joined: Mon Jun 19, 2006 3:37 am
- Location: Colorado
Criteria for salvation; what must we do?
Post #1It is a first class human tragedy that people of the earth who claim to believe in the message of Jesus, whom they describe as the Prince of Peace, show little of that belief in actual practice.
-
- Apprentice
- Posts: 232
- Joined: Sun Dec 31, 2006 2:23 pm
Re: Criteria for salvation; what must we do?
Post #2achilles12604 wrote:I have researched this myself and created a similar post in the holy huddle room. But I open it up for general discussion.
1) What exactly must be done to be saved?
2) What is the criteria used by God to determine judgement?
3) Who will be saved?
4) Who will NOT be saved?
Saved from who? Saved from what? Where does one get the idea of needing to be saved?
- achilles12604
- Site Supporter
- Posts: 3697
- Joined: Mon Jun 19, 2006 3:37 am
- Location: Colorado
Re: Criteria for salvation; what must we do?
Post #3The website is "Debating Christianity and religion" so of course I used the terms saved and salvation with regards to the Christian sense of the word. However, I have also left it open for other religions views on salvation if they care to put them forth.TruthSeeker1 wrote:achilles12604 wrote:I have researched this myself and created a similar post in the holy huddle room. But I open it up for general discussion.
1) What exactly must be done to be saved?
2) What is the criteria used by God to determine judgement?
3) Who will be saved?
4) Who will NOT be saved?
Saved from who? Saved from what? Where does one get the idea of needing to be saved?
When you re-read your post in light of the general website title, do my questions make more sense?
Also, I referred to other posts which of course answer your questions completely. Perhaps a quick reference to those would have cleared up the issues you asked about.
Here I will link them for you.
http://debatingchristianity.com/forum/v ... php?t=5737
It is a first class human tragedy that people of the earth who claim to believe in the message of Jesus, whom they describe as the Prince of Peace, show little of that belief in actual practice.
Post #4
I have absolutely no idea as to the exact requirements of salvation. I am not one to judge such things; only Jesus can.
If I were to guess, I could only venture to say that people who outright disobeye the two great commandments of loving God and loving your neighbor are probably the ones more likely to not have salvation. I don't know what it would enail for one to truly disobeye each commandment, nor to what degree they need to disobeye to be denied salvation.
The only people I would think are very likely to be denied salvation are people like the pharisees who have seen for themselves the undeniable power and grace of God but despise it and favor their own desires. I suppose anyone who favors their desires to the point where they have complete disregard for others life and wellbeing is someone who would not be saved.
If I were to guess, I could only venture to say that people who outright disobeye the two great commandments of loving God and loving your neighbor are probably the ones more likely to not have salvation. I don't know what it would enail for one to truly disobeye each commandment, nor to what degree they need to disobeye to be denied salvation.
The only people I would think are very likely to be denied salvation are people like the pharisees who have seen for themselves the undeniable power and grace of God but despise it and favor their own desires. I suppose anyone who favors their desires to the point where they have complete disregard for others life and wellbeing is someone who would not be saved.
Post #5
I would like to expand on the redirected questions of TruthSeeker1.
Before the concept of "salvation" can become a valid criteria for discussion under the heading of "Apologia" the question of "why?" must be satisfied. Under the original posting of this OP as a point of doctrine then that would be a given, but in the context of apologia you must explain to be why I need "saving". I am not in a situation that requires such assistance, and I do not accept that the emotions of others can place me in such a situation.
Now with that stated, let me ask why am I needing this "salvation", from who or what am I being "saved", and what evidence exists that this is even a valid line of inquiry or discussion?
Before the concept of "salvation" can become a valid criteria for discussion under the heading of "Apologia" the question of "why?" must be satisfied. Under the original posting of this OP as a point of doctrine then that would be a given, but in the context of apologia you must explain to be why I need "saving". I am not in a situation that requires such assistance, and I do not accept that the emotions of others can place me in such a situation.
Now with that stated, let me ask why am I needing this "salvation", from who or what am I being "saved", and what evidence exists that this is even a valid line of inquiry or discussion?
- achilles12604
- Site Supporter
- Posts: 3697
- Joined: Mon Jun 19, 2006 3:37 am
- Location: Colorado
Post #6
Actually I agree totally. However, this can lead to beliefs which the general church simply wont accept, like mine.jgh7 wrote:I have absolutely no idea as to the exact requirements of salvation. I am not one to judge such things; only Jesus can.
Thanks for your thoughts.If I were to guess, I could only venture to say that people who outright disobeye the two great commandments of loving God and loving your neighbor are probably the ones more likely to not have salvation. I don't know what it would enail for one to truly disobeye each commandment, nor to what degree they need to disobeye to be denied salvation.
The only people I would think are very likely to be denied salvation are people like the pharisees who have seen for themselves the undeniable power and grace of God but despise it and favor their own desires. I suppose anyone who favors their desires to the point where they have complete disregard for others life and wellbeing is someone who would not be saved.
It is a first class human tragedy that people of the earth who claim to believe in the message of Jesus, whom they describe as the Prince of Peace, show little of that belief in actual practice.
-
- Student
- Posts: 50
- Joined: Tue Oct 16, 2007 2:01 am
Re: Criteria for salvation; what must we do?
Post #7Accept God's word as fact.1) What exactly must be done to be saved?
Pray for forgiveness when you sin.
Christians only3) Who will be saved?
Everyone else4) Who will NOT be saved?
- achilles12604
- Site Supporter
- Posts: 3697
- Joined: Mon Jun 19, 2006 3:37 am
- Location: Colorado
Post #8
All this post tries to do is take the OP off course. If you don't understand where the OP is coming from then please feel free to research Christianity and the concepts of Salvation.Rathpig wrote:I would like to expand on the redirected questions of TruthSeeker1.
Before the concept of "salvation" can become a valid criteria for discussion under the heading of "Apologia" the question of "why?" must be satisfied. Under the original posting of this OP as a point of doctrine then that would be a given, but in the context of apologia you must explain to be why I need "saving". I am not in a situation that requires such assistance, and I do not accept that the emotions of others can place me in such a situation.
Now with that stated, let me ask why am I needing this "salvation", from who or what am I being "saved", and what evidence exists that this is even a valid line of inquiry or discussion?
Now I would like to remain ON topic.
It is a first class human tragedy that people of the earth who claim to believe in the message of Jesus, whom they describe as the Prince of Peace, show little of that belief in actual practice.
Post #9
Excuse me for my failure to properly communicate my point. I thought I outlined my concerns adequately, but I will elaborate further:achilles12604 wrote: All this post tries to do is take the OP off course. If you don't understand where the OP is coming from then please feel free to research Christianity and the concepts of Salvation.
Now I would like to remain ON topic.
In the context of a discussion among Christians, you are correct that the terms would not need to be defined. However in the context of apologetics this is not exactly the case. Now I am well aware of the underlying concepts to which you are making reference. I truly intended no "derail" of your subject. In fact my questions go directly to your topic and to the context of apologetics. After all, and forgive me because I am new here, this forum section is "apologetics".
In the context of apologetics the question of "why?" is extremely topical for your subject.
Now your response raises the question to me of whether we are discussing a specific religious dogma or whether we are discussing the apologetics surrounding that dogma. If you are seeking an internal discussion between Christians then I will of course bow out as I am not of that specific demographic. However, if you wish to discuss the topic with a broader group of people then I would enjoy participation.
Once again I intended no derail and apologize if that is the perception I created.
Re: Criteria for salvation; what must we do?
Post #10If I understand the Bible correctly, nothing miust be done. Jesus said "it is finished."achilles12604 wrote:
1) What exactly must be done to be saved?
Apparently by how what we believe about the words "It is finished." What we believe about them will influence our whole life. If we believe He finshed it, then we will not strive to finish it ourselves.2) What is the criteria used by God to determine judgement?
Those who believe Jesus finished it.3) Who will be saved?
Everyone else.4) Who will NOT be saved?