JEALOUSY: A good attribute in a god?

Argue for and against Christianity

Moderator: Moderators

Post Reply

Is jealousy a good attribute in a god?

Yes
2
22%
No
7
78%
Don't know
0
No votes
 
Total votes: 9

2Dbunk
Site Supporter
Posts: 838
Joined: Tue Sep 01, 2015 1:39 pm
Location: East of Eden

JEALOUSY: A good attribute in a god?

Post #1

Post by 2Dbunk »

Exodus 20:5
You shall not bow down to them or worship them; for I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God, punishing the children for the sin of the parents to the third and fourth generation of those who hate me,
The above is strong stuff. In a land that cherishes the choices Capitalism has provided us with, and Freedom beyond "free will," we Americans welcome competition. But the Abrahamic God would proscribe that right and, in the face of our Constitution, punish offender's children thru the 3rd and 4th generation. IMO that's a bit harsh for children to suffer for something they had no say or control about. IMO this, alone, points to human authorship of the Bible, as flawed as this command is.

1) Is it necessary for God to be jealous in light of the fact he has given us free will and has access to everything there is anyway?

2) Is it necessary for God to be jealous at all?

User avatar
Peds nurse
Site Supporter
Posts: 2270
Joined: Tue Nov 04, 2014 7:27 am
Been thanked: 9 times

Re: JEALOUSY: A good attribute in a god?

Post #61

Post by Peds nurse »

PN wrote:I see God in nature. I suppose, the difference is what we are tuned in to. I am tuned into God's spirit. When I see a flower, I think of it's beautiful color, and the splendor of its beauty. This takes me to a verse where it tells us to not worry. If God clothes the flowers in such beauty, will he not meet our needs as well? So, I say a thank you to God, for his provisions in my life.

...

Why does science have to disprove God? Just because we know what makes a flower colorful, doesn't mean that God didn't create it to happen. There is beauty everywhere, and how do we know that someone doesn't see it? Some one dove down into the depths of the sea to experience it, correct? The beauty of the ocean, and the order there, is far more convincing of God's hand, than random chance.

...

He speaks to me through everyday things, situations, and people. Once I remember walking, and I asked God to give me a glimpse of how much he loves his people. I was so overwhelmed with love, but for a brief second, that I couldn't even breathe. It brought me to my knees.
HS wrote:Unlike you, I have been to the bottom of the sea, many, many times. The real point is that concepts such as "god" are just unnecessary noise in the system that prevents clear vision and thinking and that confusticate "truth" by providing simplistic answers thus obviating a complete understanding of nature's beauty and function. A detailed understanding of natural selection and evolutionary stable solutions are worth far more both in terms of usefulness and aesthetic appreciation than all the hosannas, hallelujahs, yea Gods, and hail Marys that have been served up since the beginning of time.
Peds nurse wrote: You are obviously very intelligent H.S., and I gather a lover of science.
H.Sapiens wrote:I realize that you are a very nice person who is doing what comes naturally to you, but I do not need stroking, in fact, I find it somewhat distasteful in that it is, to my upbringing, rather personal and presumptuous.

I wasn't directly trying to "stroke" you, or insult you in anyway. I was making an observation.
PN wrote: I am not undermining science, and the usefulness that gives to humanity.
H.Sapiens wrote:You may not realize it, it may not be intentional, but yes ... you undermine both science and the future of the human race. As long as people are told that there is a more powerful entity who can either destroy or fix at will, they will not grow up and understand and take full responsibility for their actions. We're way past our childhood's end.
I believe that you give credit, where it is not due. People don't take responsibility for actions, and most of the time, at least from my experience, it has nothing to do with religion. It has everything to do with pride.
Peds nurse wrote: Spiritually however, it gives nothing, and that my friend is worth more than science can offer in a millennium.
H.Sapiens wrote:"Spirituality" is neither demonstrable nor demonstrably useful.
If you believe that to be true, then you have never seen a child die, for in them is the greatest hope. Hope is useful because it propels us to keep going...despite the ugly things that happen.
HS wrote:Besides, you've got it backward, there is no need to "disprove" God, in fact, it is quite impossible to prove a negative and thus it is absurd to attempt or suggest that it be done.
Peds nurse wrote: I am going to be honest here, HS, and probably show my ineptness at debate (which I am sure is already known),
H.Sapiens wrote:If you don't understand the basic concepts of a debate what are you doing as a moderator on a site that is titled: "Debating Christianity and Religion?"


Excellent question! I suppose that my extreme love for the people on this forum, and my passion for civil dialogue, has been noticed. It certainly isn't because I debate well.

2Dbunk
Site Supporter
Posts: 838
Joined: Tue Sep 01, 2015 1:39 pm
Location: East of Eden

Re: Is jealousy a good attribute in a god?

Post #62

Post by 2Dbunk »

[Replying to post 58 by ttruscott]

Sorry to get back to you so late -- I was on an 8-day holiday.

[Replying to post 45 by ttruscott]

You are arguing the failure of the analogy to be real. It does not reflect human reality but it does reflect a manner of thinking even the most jaded person can sympathize with.

Arguing against the analogy is fruitless and meaningless.
2Dbunk wrote-

I AM GROUNDED IN REALITY !!
-------------------------
Arguing against the analogy is not being ungrounded in reality but being illogical. As it seems you still are.


If I'm grounded in reality, how can that be illogical? I make my decisions, live my life based on the reality of it all. I have found extraordinary success in doing so.
2Dbunk wrote-

You, my friend , are on cloud nine. Reality is all we have.
--------------------------------
So what? My reality is obviously far different from yours. Prove my reality is wrong, eh?
I can't do that! I'm not inclined to dwell on dreams of the third kind.

2Dbunk wrote-

You may think you have earned eternal bliss but I don't see that as a proven future.
------------------------------
How could you - you have not been initiated into the truth of the Spirit.
I abhor initiations. You'll have to take me as I am -- a seeker of truth as I see it, experience it, within the bounds of Reason. I don't go looking for things outside those bounds.
2Dbunk wrote-

Doesn't the internecine bickering of different sects move you? It moves me to a great degree of disgust.
----------------------
Of course it did. It also sent me on a quest to understand how to reconcile all of them in fact if not in reality. I found that reconciliation and that is what I teach.
Fact and reality are synonymous. You have reconciled by looking down at other faiths. Your task isn't complete until you've dismissed them all, and recognize facts -- all of them -- as the sum total of reality.
Your disgust is a immaterial to me or to the argument - did it really help all that much to focus your attention???
Hey! This is debate -- I try (not always succeeding) to stay focused. I'm sorry that what disgusts me is "immaterial" to you, but I think there are some on this forum that will agree that internecine bickering is childish and sometimes dangerous.

2Dbunk wrote-

You are right, arguing with you is fruitless and meaningless.
-----------------------------------
Ahhh, non-logic and then personal attack. I will not presume to guess why you devolved so quickly...
To Shay! I apologize for my abruptness. I hope the above answers show that I'm devolving more slowly -- if at all.
_________________
I Champion:

GODs holiness:
- GOD did not need evil to fulfill HIS plan and did not create evil or evil people for any reason.
- All evil is creature-created by their true free will.

Our Free will:
- All spirits created in the image of GOD were created with the ability to make true free will decisions.
- All spirits had an equal ability to choose GOD or reject HIM.

2Dbunk
Site Supporter
Posts: 838
Joined: Tue Sep 01, 2015 1:39 pm
Location: East of Eden

Re: Is jealousy a good attribute in a god?

Post #63

Post by 2Dbunk »

[Replying to post 62 by 2Dbunk]

Somehow I attached Ttruscott's signature refrains to my previous post. I do not agree with most of his/her's refrains. My apology for any confusion. My signature refrains are listed below
What good is truth if its value is not more than unproven, handed-down faith?

One believes things because one is conditioned to believe them. -Aldous Huxley

Fear within the Religious will always be with them ... as long as they are fearful of death.

Post Reply