Favorite arguments AGAINST your position

[Rational Atheist]

Theists: if any argument could theoretically convince you to be an atheist, what would it be?

Same question to atheist about theism.

For me, the fine tuning argument is my favorite theistic argument because I think it's the only one that actually raises legitimate and interesting questions about the universe.

[William]

Theists: if any argument could theoretically convince you to be an atheist, what would it be?

Same question to atheist about theism.

For me, the fine tuning argument is my favorite theistic argument because I think it's the only one that actually raises legitimate and interesting questions about the universe.

I think that if science could verify with certainty that we cannot possibly be existing within a Creation [reality simulation], then I would be able to cease being an agnostic.
(I am an agnostic theist)

[Miles]

Theists: if any argument could theoretically convince you to be an atheist, what would it be?

Same question to atheist about theism.

For me, the fine tuning argument is my favorite theistic argument because I think it's the only one that actually raises legitimate and interesting questions about the universe.

(An atheist here) Convincing evidence.


.

[John Bauer]

Theists: if any argument could theoretically convince you to be an atheist, what would it be?

One that doesn't involve begging the question against my view, which doesn't seem to exist yet (i.e., every argument against my view that I have encountered involves a question-begging move). When someone formulates such an argument, I would find it compelling.

[nobspeople]

Theists: if any argument could theoretically convince you to be an atheist, what would it be?

Same question to atheist about theism.

For me, the fine tuning argument is my favorite theistic argument because I think it's the only one that actually raises legitimate and interesting questions about the universe.

As a former Christian, but still not an atheist, I'd want - correction I STILL WANT - proof of God that would satisfy my own judgement, not someone else's.
Been waiting for decades and still waiting.