Can Atheism ground objective morality?

For the love of the pursuit of knowledge

Moderator: Moderators

Post Reply
User avatar
The Tanager
Savant
Posts: 6344
Joined: Wed May 06, 2015 11:08 am
Has thanked: 97 times
Been thanked: 284 times

Can Atheism ground objective morality?

Post #1

Post by The Tanager »

In my exploration and discussions, I have not seen an atheistic worldview be able to logically account for morality being objective. The closest I've seen is an atheistic platonic kind of moral system, but while that seems to be able to account for the existence of 'good' and 'evil', it still doesn't seem to account for why humans would be obligated to choose Good over Evil. I'd love to hear cases from those who think atheism can account for objective morality to make sure I haven't missed (or misunderstood) thoughts in my exploration.

User avatar
William
Savant
Posts: 16499
Joined: Tue Jul 31, 2012 8:11 pm
Location: Te Waipounamu
Has thanked: 1038 times
Been thanked: 1951 times
Contact:

Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?

Post #191

Post by William »

Tanager - perhaps your OP is best read as an enthymeme, with two unstated premises:

"If atheism can't ground objective morality, then theism is the most plausible ground."
and
"If theism can account for objective morality, then objective morality is evidence for theism."

Both are big "ifs," and I'd like to see them defended rather than assumed.

On your positive account, objective morality is grounded in the natures God gave beings and the purpose he designed them for. But here's the problem: the natures God gave beings include both help and harm - empathy and aggression, cooperation and consumption. So the nature alone doesn't yield a determinate morality; it has to be the purpose that does the work. But the purpose is asserted, not derived from the nature. And an asserted purpose is subjectively sourced - it's posited rather than read off what is. So the grounding collapses into subjectivism at exactly the joint where it needs to be objective.

This matters comparatively. Both theist and atheist can hold and act on moral beliefs; both can bring a sense of ought into the world and try to live by it. The question is what grounds them. The theist grounds them in a particular claim about the designer's nature; the atheist grounds them elsewhere or denies they need a cosmic ground. So the real question is whether the theist's grounding does the work it claims - and the design itself gives reason to doubt that it does.

This is the same structure I see in the Eden story and in the biology. A rule is imposed on a nature that pulls against it; the creature is caught between the rule and the biology; and the dualism of God vs. Devil is the externalized version of that split - the good rule gets a cosmic author, the rebellious impulse gets a cosmic adversary, and the human is the battlefield. But the dualism doesn't resolve the contradiction; it just relocates it. Two entities vying doesn't explain why the nature is split; it just personifies the split.

So the onus is on the theist to state why the designer's nature ought to be as stated...why the purpose is the empathic one rather than the aggressive one, and why an asserted purpose grounds obligation rather than just expressing a preference. The atheist is under no obligation to accept a grounding that hasn't been shown to work, and the design itself gives reason to doubt that it does. As far as I can see, the theistic grounding doesn't account for this. If I'm misunderstanding your position, I'm happy to be corrected.
Image

The question has never been whether God is speaking. The question has always been whether there is anyone listening - anyone who has stopped hiding long enough to hear.

Post Reply