Questions For Atheists

For the love of the pursuit of knowledge

Moderator: Moderators

Post Reply
User avatar
The Mad Haranguer
Under Probation
Posts: 221
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2010 1:21 pm

Questions For Atheists

Post #1

Post by The Mad Haranguer »

What is ironic about atheists’ demand for evidence is that there is not one shred of evidence indicating that the material universe is anything but a shadow of the Real. I can show you, atheists, evidence of a reality beyond all determination. Were is your evidence that matter-energy is the bottom line? Why is it human to limit our response to being, to the Great Unknown, by making the outside the only inside? Why is it delusion to make the inside part of the outside?

Accurate beliefs and objective facts are no doubt crucial to survival. Perhaps belief in God aids in survival, a delusion caused by our biology and psychological needs. But if this is so, atheism is an aberration or mutation of some kind. So, how do the mutants know whether it is believers in the Divine or themselves that are deluded? If the question of truth is determined by its survival-value, we’ll just have to wait. But if truth is something other than success, if it is an intrinsic value that cannot be measured by its conduciveness to survival, then the determination of truth takes place above and beyond the physical.

Down through the ages, philosophers, prophets and sages have been telling us that that the real world exists in and of itself and that we are wrong to believe in the ultimate reality of what our senses tell us, that to know the reality of Being it is necessary to perceive it with more than the intellect alone. It must be felt. To know with the intellect alone is to know about things, but not being itself where meaning resides. Are they delusional? Where is your evidence, atheists? If you cannot so much as present evidence that the material universe is the Real, on what basis do you question the philosophers, prophets and sages?
"Concepts do not rise to the level of what it is to be human." — The Mad Haranguer

User avatar
McCulloch
Site Supporter
Posts: 24063
Joined: Mon May 02, 2005 9:10 pm
Location: Toronto, ON, CA
Been thanked: 3 times

Post #2

Post by McCulloch »

We know that the material world does exist. Anything beyond that is mere speculation. Yet, theists have for time immemorial, have been presenting their speculations about this other realm as being facts. There just might be a spiritual realm, a place that is not a place, a time without time. What do we know about this place? What do we know about its inhabitants? nothing.
Examine everything carefully; hold fast to that which is good.
First Epistle to the Church of the Thessalonians
The truth will make you free.
Gospel of John

User avatar
The Mad Haranguer
Under Probation
Posts: 221
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2010 1:21 pm

Post #3

Post by The Mad Haranguer »

McCulloch wrote:We know that the material world does exist. Anything beyond that is mere speculation. Yet, theists have for time immemorial, have been presenting their speculations about this other realm as being facts. There just might be a spiritual realm, a place that is not a place, a time without time. What do we know about this place? What do we know about its inhabitants? nothing.
I did not say that the material order does not exist.

I'm asking for evidence that it is the bottom line; evidence that what the philosophers, prophets and sages taught throughout the ages are mere speculations.
"Concepts do not rise to the level of what it is to be human." — The Mad Haranguer

User avatar
ChaosBorders
Site Supporter
Posts: 1966
Joined: Sat Mar 06, 2010 12:16 am
Location: Austin

Post #4

Post by ChaosBorders »

The Mad Haranguer wrote:
McCulloch wrote:We know that the material world does exist. Anything beyond that is mere speculation. Yet, theists have for time immemorial, have been presenting their speculations about this other realm as being facts. There just might be a spiritual realm, a place that is not a place, a time without time. What do we know about this place? What do we know about its inhabitants? nothing.
I did not say that the material order does not exist.

I'm asking for evidence that it is the bottom line; evidence that what the philosophers, prophets and sages taught throughout the ages are mere speculations.
Very few non-theists make the claim that it definitively IS the bottom line. It is simply the bottom of the lines we can accurately claim anything about, and they do not see a point in believing in lines speculated below that.

User avatar
JoeyKnothead
Banned
Banned
Posts: 20879
Joined: Fri Jun 06, 2008 10:59 am
Location: Here
Has thanked: 4093 times
Been thanked: 2573 times

Re: Questions For Atheists

Post #5

Post by JoeyKnothead »

The Mad Haranguer wrote:What is ironic about atheists’ demand for evidence is that there is not one shred of evidence indicating that the material universe is anything but a shadow of the Real. I can show you, atheists, evidence of a reality beyond all determination. Were is your evidence that matter-energy is the bottom line? Why is it human to limit our response to being, to the Great Unknown, by making the outside the only inside? Why is it delusion to make the inside part of the outside?

Accurate beliefs and objective facts are no doubt crucial to survival. Perhaps belief in God aids in survival, a delusion caused by our biology and psychological needs. But if this is so, atheism is an aberration or mutation of some kind. So, how do the mutants know whether it is believers in the Divine or themselves that are deluded? If the question of truth is determined by its survival-value, we’ll just have to wait. But if truth is something other than success, if it is an intrinsic value that cannot be measured by its conduciveness to survival, then the determination of truth takes place above and beyond the physical.

Down through the ages, philosophers, prophets and sages have been telling us that that the real world exists in and of itself and that we are wrong to believe in the ultimate reality of what our senses tell us, that to know the reality of Being it is necessary to perceive it with more than the intellect alone. It must be felt. To know with the intellect alone is to know about things, but not being itself where meaning resides. Are they delusional? Where is your evidence, atheists? If you cannot so much as present evidence that the material universe is the Real, on what basis do you question the philosophers, prophets and sages?
I propose you place this OP in the "Questions for Philosophers" section.

Atheism is a lack of belief in a god or gods.
I might be Teddy Roosevelt, but I ain't.
-Punkinhead Martin

User avatar
McCulloch
Site Supporter
Posts: 24063
Joined: Mon May 02, 2005 9:10 pm
Location: Toronto, ON, CA
Been thanked: 3 times

Post #6

Post by McCulloch »

The Mad Haranguer wrote: I'm asking for evidence that it is the bottom line; evidence that what the philosophers, prophets and sages taught throughout the ages are mere speculations.
That which is promoted as being true, based on faith rather than evidence is speculation.

Angels, demons, gods, God, Satan, djin, ghosts, fairies, archangels, heaven, hell, Valhalla, the Garden of Eden, talking serpents, six days of creation, giants, the flood, God's avenging fire, the Fates, the spirit world, telepathy, astrology, magic, potions, prayer, atonement, redemption, transubstantiation, spells, exorcism, winged horses, ritual sacrifice ...

Got any evidence that any of it is more real than the others?
Examine everything carefully; hold fast to that which is good.
First Epistle to the Church of the Thessalonians
The truth will make you free.
Gospel of John

User avatar
Goat
Site Supporter
Posts: 24999
Joined: Fri Jul 21, 2006 6:09 pm
Has thanked: 25 times
Been thanked: 207 times

Post #7

Post by Goat »

McCulloch wrote:
The Mad Haranguer wrote: I'm asking for evidence that it is the bottom line; evidence that what the philosophers, prophets and sages taught throughout the ages are mere speculations.
That which is promoted as being true, based on faith rather than evidence is speculation.

Angels, demons, gods, God, Satan, djin, ghosts, fairies, archangels, heaven, hell, Valhalla, the Garden of Eden, talking serpents, six days of creation, giants, the flood, God's avenging fire, the Fates, the spirit world, telepathy, astrology, magic, potions, prayer, atonement, redemption, transubstantiation, spells, exorcism, winged horses, ritual sacrifice ...

Got any evidence that any of it is more real than the others?
Prayer and ritual sacrifice exist. People do them all the time. Are they effective??? That is a different matter.
“What do you think science is? There is nothing magical about science. It is simply a systematic way for carefully and thoroughly observing nature and using consistent logic to evaluate results. So which part of that exactly do you disagree with? Do you disagree with being thorough? Using careful observation? Being systematic? Or using consistent logic?�

Steven Novella

User avatar
The Mad Haranguer
Under Probation
Posts: 221
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2010 1:21 pm

Post #8

Post by The Mad Haranguer »

Goat wrote: That which is promoted as being true, based on faith rather than evidence is speculation.

Angels, demons, gods, God, Satan, djin, ghosts, fairies, archangels, heaven, hell, Valhalla, the Garden of Eden, talking serpents, six days of creation, giants, the flood, God's avenging fire, the Fates, the spirit world, telepathy, astrology, magic, potions, prayer, atonement, redemption, transubstantiation, spells, exorcism, winged horses, ritual sacrifice ...Got any evidence that any of it is more real than the others?

Prayer and ritual sacrifice exist. People do them all the time. Are they effective??? That is a different matter.
ChaosBorders wrote:
The Mad Haranguer wrote:
McCulloch wrote:We know that the material world does exist. Anything beyond that is mere speculation. Yet, theists have for time immemorial, have been presenting their speculations about this other realm as being facts. There just might be a spiritual realm, a place that is not a place, a time without time. What do we know about this place? What do we know about its inhabitants? nothing.
I did not say that the material order does not exist.

I'm asking for evidence that it is the bottom line; evidence that what the philosophers, prophets and sages taught throughout the ages are mere speculations.
Very few non-theists make the claim that it definitively IS the bottom line. It is simply the bottom of the lines we can accurately claim anything about, and they do not see a point in believing in lines speculated below that.
"...to know the reality of Being it is necessary to perceive it with more than the intellect alone."
"Concepts do not rise to the level of what it is to be human." — The Mad Haranguer

User avatar
The Mad Haranguer
Under Probation
Posts: 221
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2010 1:21 pm

Re: Questions For Atheists

Post #9

Post by The Mad Haranguer »

JoeyKnothead wrote:
The Mad Haranguer wrote:What is ironic about atheists’ demand for evidence is that there is not one shred of evidence indicating that the material universe is anything but a shadow of the Real. I can show you, atheists, evidence of a reality beyond all determination. Were is your evidence that matter-energy is the bottom line? Why is it human to limit our response to being, to the Great Unknown, by making the outside the only inside? Why is it delusion to make the inside part of the outside?

Accurate beliefs and objective facts are no doubt crucial to survival. Perhaps belief in God aids in survival, a delusion caused by our biology and psychological needs. But if this is so, atheism is an aberration or mutation of some kind. So, how do the mutants know whether it is believers in the Divine or themselves that are deluded? If the question of truth is determined by its survival-value, we’ll just have to wait. But if truth is something other than success, if it is an intrinsic value that cannot be measured by its conduciveness to survival, then the determination of truth takes place above and beyond the physical.

Down through the ages, philosophers, prophets and sages have been telling us that that the real world exists in and of itself and that we are wrong to believe in the ultimate reality of what our senses tell us, that to know the reality of Being it is necessary to perceive it with more than the intellect alone. It must be felt. To know with the intellect alone is to know about things, but not being itself where meaning resides. Are they delusional? Where is your evidence, atheists? If you cannot so much as present evidence that the material universe is the Real, on what basis do you question the philosophers, prophets and sages?
I propose you place this OP in the "Questions for Philosophers" section.

Atheism is a lack of belief in a god or gods.
I'm looking for evidence that matter-energy is the bottom line. I don't care what you don't believe.
I WANT EVIDENCE!
"Concepts do not rise to the level of what it is to be human." — The Mad Haranguer

User avatar
Ooberman
Banned
Banned
Posts: 4262
Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 6:02 pm
Location: Philadelphia

Re: Questions For Atheists

Post #10

Post by Ooberman »

The Mad Haranguer wrote:I'm looking for evidence that matter-energy is the bottom line. I don't care what you don't believe.
I WANT EVIDENCE!
Matter-energy-space-time.

What else is there? I can't think of anything. Care to suggest something?

I would think the existence of Matter-energy-space-time would be evidence of M-E-S-T.... but, hey, I'm no high-falootin' philosopher.

As for it being all there is? I don't know. Could be, but why would there be?

Post Reply