Were the Nazis justified in the genocide of the Jews?

Argue for and against Christianity

Moderator: Moderators

no evidence no belief
Banned
Banned
Posts: 1507
Joined: Sat Dec 29, 2012 10:18 pm

Were the Nazis justified in the genocide of the Jews?

Post #1

Post by no evidence no belief »

Were the Nazis justified in the genocide of the Jews?

According to TheTruth101, apparently they were.

He writes:
Hitler was a Christian and mass murdered the Jews. It's a pay back, or, eye for an eye, for what the Jews did to Christ.

Problem lies when masses think of Christ as benevolent, when he carries characters of omnipotence as well. Therefore, they must be of flowers to be his follower.

Simply not true. To a fella bretheren, its proper conduct to be genuine and respectable, but, to an opposition, no mercy.

This ofcourse goes with scriptures as well and can be given if one requests.

Question for debate: Based on my various statements on this board, and based on the statements of TheTruth101, who do you think it would be easier for a ruthless and charismatic dictator to brainwash into committing genocide, me or him?

d.thomas
Sage
Posts: 713
Joined: Sat Mar 31, 2007 12:31 am
Location: British Columbia

Post #11

Post by d.thomas »

alive wrote:
d.thomas wrote: It was popular in Europe to hate the Jews at the time of Hitler. They were not justified in killing Jews but they probably believed they were justified because as Hitler put it, the Jews killed his God. The gospel story blames the Jews, the Jewish crowd called for Jesus' execution and for Barabbas' release. I don't believe that any of the story is true, and even if it were I don't believe anyone is justified in killing anyone because of what is written in a religious text, but that's just me, I am not a religious person.

Yes it was popular then...But look back further before WW1... To see where Im coming from..
I don't care, I don't want to read that they had it coming, no one is guilty for what their supposed ancestors did or did not do, and there is nothing that anyone did that justifies the holocaust.

alive
Sage
Posts: 753
Joined: Fri May 04, 2012 12:35 am
Location: Earth

Post #12

Post by alive »

d.thomas wrote:
alive wrote:
d.thomas wrote: It was popular in Europe to hate the Jews at the time of Hitler. They were not justified in killing Jews but they probably believed they were justified because as Hitler put it, the Jews killed his God. The gospel story blames the Jews, the Jewish crowd called for Jesus' execution and for Barabbas' release. I don't believe that any of the story is true, and even if it were I don't believe anyone is justified in killing anyone because of what is written in a religious text, but that's just me, I am not a religious person.

Yes it was popular then...But look back further before WW1... To see where Im coming from..
I don't care, I don't want to read that they had it coming, no one is guilty for what their supposed ancestors did or did not do, and there is nothing that anyone did that justifies the holocaust.

Just want to say they may of did some holocausting of their own... And at some point in that region the amount of peeps they ticked off well they really wern't going to get much sympathy around there..

TheTruth101
Banned
Banned
Posts: 2761
Joined: Sun Nov 11, 2012 6:51 pm
Location: CA

Post #13

Post by TheTruth101 »

alive wrote:
d.thomas wrote:
alive wrote:
d.thomas wrote: It was popular in Europe to hate the Jews at the time of Hitler. They were not justified in killing Jews but they probably believed they were justified because as Hitler put it, the Jews killed his God. The gospel story blames the Jews, the Jewish crowd called for Jesus' execution and for Barabbas' release. I don't believe that any of the story is true, and even if it were I don't believe anyone is justified in killing anyone because of what is written in a religious text, but that's just me, I am not a religious person.

Yes it was popular then...But look back further before WW1... To see where Im coming from..
I don't care, I don't want to read that they had it coming, no one is guilty for what their supposed ancestors did or did not do, and there is nothing that anyone did that justifies the holocaust.

Just want to say they may of did some holocausting of their own... And at some point in that region the amount of peeps they ticked off well they really wern't going to get much sympathy around there..


Exactly.

You know the Atheists claiming God do NOT exist? Its the same thing. They are murdering God every time they say that. Hence, he dosent exist.

Same thing as Saints as to an Atheist in eternity. We wont have sympathy at all, and hell begins for the Atheists. (place of torture, for all eternity)
"And you will know my name is the Lord when I lay my vengeance upon thee." -Ezkiel
"The big bang theory is just a detailed information of Genesis verse 1, and 2."

alive
Sage
Posts: 753
Joined: Fri May 04, 2012 12:35 am
Location: Earth

Post #14

Post by alive »

TheTruth101 wrote:
alive wrote:
d.thomas wrote:
alive wrote:
d.thomas wrote: It was popular in Europe to hate the Jews at the time of Hitler. They were not justified in killing Jews but they probably believed they were justified because as Hitler put it, the Jews killed his God. The gospel story blames the Jews, the Jewish crowd called for Jesus' execution and for Barabbas' release. I don't believe that any of the story is true, and even if it were I don't believe anyone is justified in killing anyone because of what is written in a religious text, but that's just me, I am not a religious person.

Yes it was popular then...But look back further before WW1... To see where Im coming from..
I don't care, I don't want to read that they had it coming, no one is guilty for what their supposed ancestors did or did not do, and there is nothing that anyone did that justifies the holocaust.

Just want to say they may of did some holocausting of their own... And at some point in that region the amount of peeps they ticked off well they really wern't going to get much sympathy around there..


Exactly.

You know the Atheists claiming God do NOT exist? Its the same thing. They are murdering God every time they say that. Hence, he dosent exist.

Same thing as Saints as to an Atheist in eternity. We wont have sympathy at all, and hell begins for the Atheists. (place of torture, for all eternity)

Well... Then its a good thing hell dont exist then huh?

d.thomas
Sage
Posts: 713
Joined: Sat Mar 31, 2007 12:31 am
Location: British Columbia

Post #15

Post by d.thomas »

This video has Bjorn ending up in a place worse than Hell:


The Saga of Bjorn:


http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=pl ... V5w262XvCU

alive
Sage
Posts: 753
Joined: Fri May 04, 2012 12:35 am
Location: Earth

Post #16

Post by alive »

d.thomas wrote: This video has Bjorn ending up in a place worse than Hell:


The Saga of Bjorn:


http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=pl ... V5w262XvCU
poor guy...

Justin108
Banned
Banned
Posts: 4471
Joined: Wed Oct 10, 2012 5:28 am

Re: Were the Nazis justified in the genocide of the Jews?

Post #17

Post by Justin108 »

alive wrote:
no evidence no belief wrote: Were the Nazis justified in the genocide of the Jews?

According to TheTruth101, apparently they were.

He writes:
Hitler was a Christian and mass murdered the Jews. It's a pay back, or, eye for an eye, for what the Jews did to Christ.

Problem lies when masses think of Christ as benevolent, when he carries characters of omnipotence as well. Therefore, they must be of flowers to be his follower.

Simply not true. To a fella bretheren, its proper conduct to be genuine and respectable, but, to an opposition, no mercy.

This ofcourse goes with scriptures as well and can be given if one requests.

Question for debate: Based on my various statements on this board, and based on the statements of TheTruth101, who do you think it would be easier for a ruthless and charismatic dictator to brainwash into committing genocide, me or him?

Justified? Probably not... But I see why so many including the Germans hating them...They went out of their way to tick people off way before WW1...Payback is probably more likely was the thought process.
1. Since when is ticking someone off a good reason for genocide?
2. What parts did the jewish children have in ticking Germans off in WW1?

Justin108
Banned
Banned
Posts: 4471
Joined: Wed Oct 10, 2012 5:28 am

Post #18

Post by Justin108 »

TheTruth101 wrote:
alive wrote:
d.thomas wrote:
alive wrote:
d.thomas wrote: It was popular in Europe to hate the Jews at the time of Hitler. They were not justified in killing Jews but they probably believed they were justified because as Hitler put it, the Jews killed his God. The gospel story blames the Jews, the Jewish crowd called for Jesus' execution and for Barabbas' release. I don't believe that any of the story is true, and even if it were I don't believe anyone is justified in killing anyone because of what is written in a religious text, but that's just me, I am not a religious person.

Yes it was popular then...But look back further before WW1... To see where Im coming from..
I don't care, I don't want to read that they had it coming, no one is guilty for what their supposed ancestors did or did not do, and there is nothing that anyone did that justifies the holocaust.

Just want to say they may of did some holocausting of their own... And at some point in that region the amount of peeps they ticked off well they really wern't going to get much sympathy around there..


Exactly.

You know the Atheists claiming God do NOT exist? Its the same thing. They are murdering God every time they say that. Hence, he dosent exist.

Same thing as Saints as to an Atheist in eternity. We wont have sympathy at all, and hell begins for the Atheists. (place of torture, for all eternity)
“Everytime a child says 'I don't believe in fairies,' there's a a little fairy somewhere that falls down dead.� - Peter Pan

User avatar
Wootah
Savant
Posts: 9487
Joined: Wed Nov 24, 2010 1:16 am
Has thanked: 228 times
Been thanked: 118 times

Post #19

Post by Wootah »

C'mon Alive be clear on what events in history justified the final solution.

User avatar
Star
Sage
Posts: 963
Joined: Wed Jan 02, 2013 11:34 pm
Location: Vancouver BC

Re: Were the Nazis justified in the genocide of the Jews?

Post #20

Post by Star »

alive wrote:
no evidence no belief wrote:
alive wrote:
no evidence no belief wrote:
alive wrote:
no evidence no belief wrote: Were the Nazis justified in the genocide of the Jews?

According to TheTruth101, apparently they were.

He writes:
Hitler was a Christian and mass murdered the Jews. It's a pay back, or, eye for an eye, for what the Jews did to Christ.

Problem lies when masses think of Christ as benevolent, when he carries characters of omnipotence as well. Therefore, they must be of flowers to be his follower.

Simply not true. To a fella bretheren, its proper conduct to be genuine and respectable, but, to an opposition, no mercy.

This ofcourse goes with scriptures as well and can be given if one requests.

Question for debate: Based on my various statements on this board, and based on the statements of TheTruth101, who do you think it would be easier for a ruthless and charismatic dictator to brainwash into committing genocide, me or him?

Justified? Probably not... But I see why so many including the Germans hating them...They went out of their way to tick people off way before WW1...Payback is probably more likely was the thought process.
Wow, please tell me you're joking.
Uh...Which part?
Oh my God

Look they in away had it coming...Maybe a little harsher and cruler than it should of been but research the history..
They "had it coming in a way" for being "annoying"? Genocide of women and children?

That's just sick. Atheism doesn't necessitate bigotry towards religious/racial minorities. Perhaps you missed the memo.

Locked