Preamble:
I have been trying to get at the foundational claims of Christianity, and started with the Adam and Eve narrative.
After making over a dozen arguments on that topic, I feel that I should take a break and offer something new... And the idea of free will comes up over and over in the arguments from Christians in defence of God's behaviour over what is sometimes called " the fruit incident " or more commonly, "the fall of man".
The free-will theodicy attempts to explain why God permits evil.
It argues God permits evil because humans possess free will and genuine choices require the possibility of wrongdoing.
If free will isn't real, then the free will theodicy fails.
I would also add that free will is never mentioned in the bible. If free will is so important to the god as to justify creating and allowing evil in our world, I find that to be a truly troubling omission.
The bible doesn't once mention such an important concept, and in fact, shows that the God actually violates people's will.. that's the opposite of promoting free will....
I am using the libertarian idea of free will because thats the kind Christians use:
Libertarian free will is the ability to choose between alternatives such that the choice is not entirely determined by prior causes or conditions.
The Bible portrays God hardening hearts, determining events, and fulfilling purposes, undermining the claim that libertarian free will is essential to God’s plan.
If you need bible references for those claims, just ask. I don't add them all here because the list is too long. Please, don't ask me to list them all in one shot. Just ask when it's relevant to your argument.
The Argument:
P1: The Bible never explicitly establishes libertarian free will as a necessary feature of human agency.
P2: The Bible repeatedly portrays God hardening hearts and determining human actions.
P3: Christian free-will theodicy depends on libertarian free will to explain why God permits evil.
C: Therefore, Christian free-will theodicy fails biblically.
The free will theodicy fails biblically
Moderator: Moderators
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 678
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 75 times
The free will theodicy fails biblically
Post #1I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 678
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 75 times
Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically
Post #31[Replying to 1213 in post #28]
Those are two different questions.
My argument is about free will, not moral accountability.
We can hold people responsible for their actions, but that doesn't prove they had the ability to choose differently.Ray: But responsibility doesn't establish free will. You are confusing moral accountability with the ability to make undetermined choices.
We can hold people accountable without assuming libertarian free will.
You: If people don't have free will and are just mindless machines doing what someone made them to do, then their actions are determined by someone else and the someone else would be guilty, if the person does something wrong.
Those are two different questions.
My argument is about free will, not moral accountability.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 678
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 75 times
Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically
Post #32[Replying to 1213 in post #29]
Are you talking about my list of 31 bible passages?Me: Yes, the bible explicitly describes the god as determining the actions of humans.
You: Sorry, at least the scriptures you gave, I don't think they explicitly describe the God as determining the actions of humans.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.
-
bjs1
- Guru
- Posts: 1171
- Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2020 12:18 pm
- Has thanked: 52 times
- Been thanked: 270 times
Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically
Post #33So you have a nuanced view of free will. It seems we are arguing the same point.Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:34 pm
We do have choices... we do have agency.. but are we determined to want those choices without restrictions of compulsions?
Determinism doesn't mean we can't choose between two options.. It means that we cannot choose FREELY without outside causes, interventions, prohibitions of all kinds.
We can choose, which means we must have freedom, but this does not eliminate some level of outside influence.
That is the free will defense. Evil is a moral choice. That choice may be to resist good influences or to give way to evil ones, but that choice is still the fundamental cause of evil.
Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge.
-Charles Darwin
-Charles Darwin
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 678
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 75 times
Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically
Post #34[Replying to bjs1 in post #33]
We can choose, which means we must have freedom, but this does not eliminate some level of outside influence.
I would go further than "some level of outside influence".
I don't think we can ever escape outside influence.
I can't for example, escape the outside influences that have made me disbelieve in any gods.
If I can change my mind, it will depend on some outside influence, like.... God showing up in a way that I can and others can detect, or some argument that defeats all of mine.
I think you are the same.. if there's some argument that defeats all of your arguments for the existence of gods, or your god, I think it's going to come from an outside influence.
If God himself shows up to you in a way that can be tested by skeptics, then, God himself would be that outside influence.
We can choose, which means we must have freedom, but this does not eliminate some level of outside influence.
I would go further than "some level of outside influence".
I don't think we can ever escape outside influence.
I can't for example, escape the outside influences that have made me disbelieve in any gods.
If I can change my mind, it will depend on some outside influence, like.... God showing up in a way that I can and others can detect, or some argument that defeats all of mine.
I think you are the same.. if there's some argument that defeats all of your arguments for the existence of gods, or your god, I think it's going to come from an outside influence.
If God himself shows up to you in a way that can be tested by skeptics, then, God himself would be that outside influence.
Last edited by Ray the atheist on Sat Nov 07, 2026 12:23 pm, edited 2 times in total.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 678
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 75 times
Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically
Post #35[Replying to bjs1 in post #33]
I don't assume that we have free will, I'm skeptical of that idea.
I need evidentiary justification for the claim.
I agree that you present a version of the free will defence..Evil is a moral choice. That choice may be to resist good influences or to give way to evil ones, but that choice is still the fundamental cause of evil.
I don't assume that we have free will, I'm skeptical of that idea.
I need evidentiary justification for the claim.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.
- 1213
- Savant
- Posts: 13811
- Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 11:06 am
- Location: Finland
- Has thanked: 555 times
- Been thanked: 530 times
Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically
Post #36Yes.Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:58 am [Replying to 1213 in post #29]
Are you talking about my list of 31 bible passages?Me: Yes, the bible explicitly describes the god as determining the actions of humans.
You: Sorry, at least the scriptures you gave, I don't think they explicitly describe the God as determining the actions of humans.
My new book can be read freely from here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rIkqxC ... xtqFY/view
Old version can be read from here:
http://web.archive.org/web/202212010403 ... x_eng.html
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rIkqxC ... xtqFY/view
Old version can be read from here:
http://web.archive.org/web/202212010403 ... x_eng.html
- 1213
- Savant
- Posts: 13811
- Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 11:06 am
- Location: Finland
- Has thanked: 555 times
- Been thanked: 530 times
Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically
Post #37If people don't have fere will, it means someone else decides what they do. And then they don't have moral accountability.Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:56 am We can hold people responsible for their actions, but that doesn't prove they had the ability to choose differently.
Those are two different questions.
My argument is about free will, not moral accountability.
My new book can be read freely from here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rIkqxC ... xtqFY/view
Old version can be read from here:
http://web.archive.org/web/202212010403 ... x_eng.html
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rIkqxC ... xtqFY/view
Old version can be read from here:
http://web.archive.org/web/202212010403 ... x_eng.html
- 1213
- Savant
- Posts: 13811
- Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 11:06 am
- Location: Finland
- Has thanked: 555 times
- Been thanked: 530 times
Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically
Post #38To me free will means only the ability to want freely. For example, if person is in jail, because he broke the tyrannical speech laws in UK, he can want to be free, but that doesn't make him free.Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:52 am ...I have been using "Libertarian Free Will" all along.
Libertarian free will is the ability to choose between genuine alternatives, where the choice is not determined by prior causes or conditions.
Some Christians might not believe in libertarian free will. You might not, and I need clarity.
What kind of free will are you talking about if not libertarian free will?
Obviously, in practice that means, if there is a choice to make, when person has free will, he can himself choose what he picks. For example, the British tough criminal could choose to be silent and free or speak what he thinks and go to jail. He can't choose to be free from jail and have freedom of speech, but because he has free will, he can want them both, he just doesn’t get all that he wants.
My new book can be read freely from here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rIkqxC ... xtqFY/view
Old version can be read from here:
http://web.archive.org/web/202212010403 ... x_eng.html
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rIkqxC ... xtqFY/view
Old version can be read from here:
http://web.archive.org/web/202212010403 ... x_eng.html
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 678
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 75 times
Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically
Post #39[Replying to 1213 in post #36]
let me know !!
I'd be happy to go through each one with you to find out why you don't think they mean what I think they do.You: Sorry, at least the scriptures you gave, I don't think they explicitly describe the God as determining the actions of humans.
Me: Are you talking about my list of 31 bible passages?
You: Yes.
let me know !!
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 678
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 75 times
Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically
Post #40[Replying to 1213 in post #38]
I think you are describing compatibilist free will, specifically the ability to choose and act according to your own desires, even when those desires are determined by prior causes.
You would need to explain in what way we are " free " when those desires are determined by prior causes.
Me: What kind of free will are you talking about if not libertarian free will?
You: To me free will means only the ability to want freely. For example, if person is in jail, because he broke the tyrannical speech laws in UK, he can want to be free, but that doesn't make him free.
Obviously, in practice that means, if there is a choice to make, when person has free will, he can himself choose what he picks. For example, the British tough criminal could choose to be silent and free or speak what he thinks and go to jail. He can't choose to be free from jail and have freedom of speech, but because he has free will, he can want them both, he just doesn’t get all that he wants.
I think you are describing compatibilist free will, specifically the ability to choose and act according to your own desires, even when those desires are determined by prior causes.
You would need to explain in what way we are " free " when those desires are determined by prior causes.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

