The free will theodicy fails biblically

Argue for and against Christianity

Moderator: Moderators

Post Reply
Ray the atheist
Sage
Posts: 678
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 75 times

The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #1

Post by Ray the atheist »

Preamble:

I have been trying to get at the foundational claims of Christianity, and started with the Adam and Eve narrative.

After making over a dozen arguments on that topic, I feel that I should take a break and offer something new... And the idea of free will comes up over and over in the arguments from Christians in defence of God's behaviour over what is sometimes called " the fruit incident " or more commonly, "the fall of man".

The free-will theodicy attempts to explain why God permits evil.

It argues God permits evil because humans possess free will and genuine choices require the possibility of wrongdoing.
If free will isn't real, then the free will theodicy fails.

I would also add that free will is never mentioned in the bible. If free will is so important to the god as to justify creating and allowing evil in our world, I find that to be a truly troubling omission.
The bible doesn't once mention such an important concept, and in fact, shows that the God actually violates people's will.. that's the opposite of promoting free will....
I am using the libertarian idea of free will because thats the kind Christians use:

Libertarian free will is the ability to choose between alternatives such that the choice is not entirely determined by prior causes or conditions.


The Bible portrays God hardening hearts, determining events, and fulfilling purposes, undermining the claim that libertarian free will is essential to God’s plan.
If you need bible references for those claims, just ask. I don't add them all here because the list is too long. Please, don't ask me to list them all in one shot. Just ask when it's relevant to your argument.

The Argument:

P1: The Bible never explicitly establishes libertarian free will as a necessary feature of human agency.
P2: The Bible repeatedly portrays God hardening hearts and determining human actions.
P3: Christian free-will theodicy depends on libertarian free will to explain why God permits evil.
C: Therefore, Christian free-will theodicy fails biblically.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

User avatar
1213
Savant
Posts: 13811
Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 11:06 am
Location: Finland
Has thanked: 555 times
Been thanked: 530 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #51

Post by 1213 »

Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 3:37 pm ...Yes, desire is a will to do something by my definitions so we agree.

If I desire something, i want it....
Nice, then I think the question is about, can you choose to want, or not to want something. If yes, then you ahve free will.
Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 3:37 pmIf I want something, there are usually reasons. Those reasons might be unknown to me and are called "subconscious" reasons unknown. When I get a strong feeling that I dont know the cause of, I think it's probably caused by something that I am not aware of, and also call it "irrational" since my reason didn't come into the desire.. I just "have" the desire or want.
In that case I think you just don't know yourself very well.
Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 3:37 pmI dont have any rational reason to love ice cream or to prefer vanilla ice cream over all other flavours ive tried so far.
I have difficulties to believe you would eat ice cream irrationally. I believe there are reasons, for example you like the taste, structure, temperature, fat, sugar… …there are many reasons to like to eat ice cream.
My new book can be read freely from here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rIkqxC ... xtqFY/view

Old version can be read from here:
http://web.archive.org/web/202212010403 ... x_eng.html

Ray the atheist
Sage
Posts: 678
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 75 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #52

Post by Ray the atheist »

[Replying to 1213 in post #50]
Me: You keep saying that we have free will, but you can't seem to prove it.

You: Neither can you prove that I don't have free will.

Me: So the two of us are admitting that we have no evidence for free will one way or the other.

You: No, because I have free will, I have proof that free will exists. But, apparently for you, there is no proof of it.

Your evidence for free will is your assertion that you have proof of free will.

Ok, show your proof, I am truly interested !!
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

Ray the atheist
Sage
Posts: 678
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 75 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #53

Post by Ray the atheist »

[Replying to 1213 in post #51]
Me: ...Yes, desire is a will to do something by my definitions so we agree.

If I desire something, i want it....

You: Nice, then I think the question is about, can you choose to want, or not to want something. If yes, then you ahve free will.
I agree if that I can choose what I want, that by the definition of libertarian free will, I would have free will.

We would have to first demonstrate that I actually freely choose what I want, and not just assume what we are trying to demonstrate is true.

Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 3:37 pm
Me: If I want something, there are usually reasons. Those reasons might be unknown to me and are called "subconscious" reasons unknown. When I get a strong feeling that I dont know the cause of, I think it's probably caused by something that I am not aware of, and also call it "irrational" since my reason didn't come into the desire.. I just "have" the desire or want.

You: In that case I think you just don't know yourself very well.

I would suggest that by definition, all humans have parts of their minds that are unknown, not just me.



Me: Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 3:37 pm
I dont have any rational reason to love ice cream or to prefer vanilla ice cream over all other flavours ive tried so far.

You: I have difficulties to believe you would eat ice cream irrationally. I believe there are reasons, for example you like the taste, structure, temperature, fat, sugar… …there are many reasons to like to eat ice cream.
I didn't say that I eat ice cream irrationally. I said that my love of ice cream is irrational. I have no rational reason to love ice cream. This is caused in my brain in a place that I have no access to.. in my subconscious mind. I would also say that biology dictates why I love sweets a bit too much in general, not just ice cream.

Yes, there are lots of reasons as you stated, but if we are looking for the cause of my love of the taste, structure, temperature, fat content, sugar of ice cream, all I can say is that I do.

Humans really love sweets... cats do not.. this different is biological, not rational.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

AchillesHeel
Apprentice
Posts: 115
Joined: Fri Sep 08, 2023 6:02 pm
Has thanked: 7 times
Been thanked: 98 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #54

Post by AchillesHeel »

The simplest way to debunk the free will theodicy is to point out that under any form of divine design, humans aren't given a free choice to exist. They're forced to, when their actions are known prior due to God being omniscient.

Since God has free will but chose to create human beings, when he could have refrained from creating them, this makes all outcomes fixed. Their fate is sealed at the moment of the decision to create them. No one forced God to create. That was his decision when he knew what would result from that decision.

This makes God the sufficient cause of all suffering, sin and evil. None of that would exist if God would have simply refrained from creating in the first place.

There is simply no way out of this one without subtracting from omniscience.

Usually, Christian apologists strawman this observation by saying "God's knowledge doesn't cause human action". I would agree but that's not what the claim is. The claim combines God's foreknowledge with the decision to create. Apologists always ignore the latter.

User avatar
tam
Savant
Posts: 7081
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2015 4:59 pm
Has thanked: 408 times
Been thanked: 376 times
Contact:

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #55

Post by tam »

Peace to you,
[Replying to AchillesHeel in post #54]

None of that (suffering, sin, evil) would exist if God would have simply refrained from creating in the first place.
But then life also would not exist. Nor love, nor peace, nor joy, nor happiness. (except in and for God, Himself.)

We would not exist. Our loved ones would not exist. Our children and grandchildren would not exist.

There is also something else that many critics forget about:

God knows how it all turns out. God knows that there will be no more suffering or mourning or death or sickness. He knows the joy of the people, the love, the hope, the mercy, the peace and happiness of these same people. Some of us may have peace and love and joy and hope in and from Christ and His Father even now.

He's not guessing. He knows.
- Non-religious Christian spirituality

- For Christ (who is the Spirit)

User avatar
1213
Savant
Posts: 13811
Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 11:06 am
Location: Finland
Has thanked: 555 times
Been thanked: 530 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #56

Post by 1213 »

AchillesHeel wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 10:05 am The simplest way to debunk the free will theodicy is to point out that under any form of divine design, humans aren't given a free choice to exist.
People can abort themselves, if they don't want to exist.
AchillesHeel wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 10:05 am...this makes all outcomes fixed....
Why do you think so? People choose their own actions. So, if the outcome is fixed, it is fixed by humans.
My new book can be read freely from here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rIkqxC ... xtqFY/view

Old version can be read from here:
http://web.archive.org/web/202212010403 ... x_eng.html

AchillesHeel
Apprentice
Posts: 115
Joined: Fri Sep 08, 2023 6:02 pm
Has thanked: 7 times
Been thanked: 98 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #57

Post by AchillesHeel »

1213 wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 5:03 am
AchillesHeel wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 10:05 am The simplest way to debunk the free will theodicy is to point out that under any form of divine design, humans aren't given a free choice to exist.
People can abort themselves, if they don't want to exist.
AchillesHeel wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 10:05 am...this makes all outcomes fixed....
Why do you think so? People choose their own actions. So, if the outcome is fixed, it is fixed by humans.
So humans just created themselves without God being involved in bringing them into existence?

Under the paradigm of divine creative freedom, God creates the souls of people whose actions are foreknown, thereby fixing the outcome. Otherwise, humans wouldn't exist to choose anything.

The only reason Bob chose to eat a cheeseburger on Tuesday is because God brought Bob into existence in a world where he knew Bob would do that. Otherwise, Bob wouldn't exist.

It all leads back to God being responsible in the end.
Last edited by AchillesHeel on Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:35 pm, edited 3 times in total.

AchillesHeel
Apprentice
Posts: 115
Joined: Fri Sep 08, 2023 6:02 pm
Has thanked: 7 times
Been thanked: 98 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #58

Post by AchillesHeel »

tam wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 3:50 pm Peace to you,
[Replying to AchillesHeel in post #54]

None of that (suffering, sin, evil) would exist if God would have simply refrained from creating in the first place.
But then life also would not exist. Nor love, nor peace, nor joy, nor happiness. (except in and for God, Himself.)

We would not exist. Our loved ones would not exist. Our children and grandchildren would not exist.

There is also something else that many critics forget about:

God knows how it all turns out. God knows that there will be no more suffering or mourning or death or sickness. He knows the joy of the people, the love, the hope, the mercy, the peace and happiness of these same people. Some of us may have peace and love and joy and hope in and from Christ and His Father even now.

He's not guessing. He knows.
You wouldn't know the difference if you didn't exist and this doesn't address the fact that God is responsible for creating evil.

User avatar
tam
Savant
Posts: 7081
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2015 4:59 pm
Has thanked: 408 times
Been thanked: 376 times
Contact:

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #59

Post by tam »

Peace to you,
AchillesHeel wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:28 pm
tam wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 3:50 pm Peace to you,
[Replying to AchillesHeel in post #54]

None of that (suffering, sin, evil) would exist if God would have simply refrained from creating in the first place.
But then life also would not exist. Nor love, nor peace, nor joy, nor happiness. (except in and for God, Himself.)

We would not exist. Our loved ones would not exist. Our children and grandchildren would not exist.

There is also something else that many critics forget about:

God knows how it all turns out. God knows that there will be no more suffering or mourning or death or sickness. He knows the joy of the people, the love, the hope, the mercy, the peace and happiness of these same people. Some of us may have peace and love and joy and hope in and from Christ and His Father even now.

He's not guessing. He knows.
You wouldn't know the difference if you didn't exist


What does that have to do with anything?
and this doesn't address the fact that God is responsible for creating evil.
God is responsible for creating life. He knew evil (sin and death) would end up entering the world and existing for a time, but He also knew that it would be overcome.

An eternity of life, love, good. A short time (especially relative to eternity), wherein sin and death reign.
- Non-religious Christian spirituality

- For Christ (who is the Spirit)

User avatar
1213
Savant
Posts: 13811
Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 11:06 am
Location: Finland
Has thanked: 555 times
Been thanked: 530 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #60

Post by 1213 »

AchillesHeel wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:28 pm So humans just created themselves without God being involved in bringing them into existence?
No.
AchillesHeel wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:28 pm Under the paradigm of divine creative freedom, God creates the souls of people whose actions are foreknown, thereby fixing the outcome. Otherwise, humans wouldn't exist to choose anything.
That actions are foreknown doesn't mean humans don't choose freely their own actions.
AchillesHeel wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:28 pm The only reason Bob chose to eat a cheeseburger on Tuesday is because God brought Bob into existence in a world where he knew Bob would do that. Otherwise, Bob wouldn't exist.
Sorry, I don't believe anyone choose to eat hamburger, because of God. People choose to eat them, because they like them.
AchillesHeel wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:28 pmIt all leads back to God being responsible in the end.
God is only responsible of His actions, not actions of others.
My new book can be read freely from here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rIkqxC ... xtqFY/view

Old version can be read from here:
http://web.archive.org/web/202212010403 ... x_eng.html

Post Reply