Anyone, even someone who would become the Pope, would've had impossible decisions to make while growing up under the Nazi government. And who knew what would happen if you did not go along with what the Nazi party ordered to do, including joining the Hitler Youth.
NARRATOR: On the April 19, 2005, white smoke rises above the roofs of Rome. A new pope has been elected. Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger becomes Pope Benedikt XVI. For the first time in centuries, a German takes the reigns of the Catholic Church. This, too, makes headlines. English newspaper The Sun runs the story From Hitler Youth to Papa Ratzi.'
BRUCE JOHNSTON: "It is obviously a shot across him in his bows, its a provocative statement."
NARRATOR: Joseph Ratzinger had been a member of the Hitler Youth and, by the end of the war, a soldier.
ADREAS ENGLISCH: "He is Christs representative on Earth, and it seemed unbelievable to the international community that he was to come from Germany, a country that started two wars in the last century."
NARRATOR: The Popes life story stirs international interest. In 1927, Ratzinger is born into a Catholic family critical of Hitler in the Bavarian town of Marktl am Inn. Hitler seeks to substitute religion with National Socialism. The Nazi state targets the Christian youth to win them for their cause. As a 12-year-old Ratzinger joins the Catholic boys seminary in Traunstein.
JOSEF STADLER: "In the seminary we were told one day that we would have to join the Hitler Youth. But nobody at the seminary joined voluntarily."
NARRATOR: During the war, the Hitler Youth is put to work in air defense. Joseph Ratzinger is assigned to track bombers and later as a telephonist, but never as a gunner.
WILHELM GEIELBRECHT: "He wasn't really interested in the military. He was glad when he was reassigned from flak duty. They left him alone, because they knew exactly what he wanted to be later on and that was accepted."
NARRATOR: Joseph Ratzinger wants to enter the priesthood, but the war is far from over. He has to guard forced laborers as they dig trenches. The young guards are equipped with rifles, but no live ammunition. Like many boys his age, the 17-year-old is courted by the Waffen-SS. But as a candidate for the priesthood, he is largely left alone. Shortly before the end of the war, Joseph Ratzinger officially becomes a soldier in Traunstein. But when U.S. troops approach the town, hes unwilling to fight.
PETER SEEWALD: "Joseph Ratzinger withdrew from active service during the time in Traunstein. He said himself 'The day came when I decided to withdraw from service and return home.' That was, of course, quite dangerous."
NARRATOR: He is lucky not to be spotted during an inspection. At the end of the war, the young Ratzinger only spends a short time in captivity and is released in July 1945.
GEROG RATZINGER: "The joy was complete, since the family had managed to survive the war, while so many others we knew had lost someone in the field. We were all very thankful that we all managed to come home again."
NARRATOR: Summer 2005, 50 years after the war, Joseph Ratzinger returns to his homeland as Pope.
https://www.britannica.com/video/180295 ... ent-Hitler
So, to answer my questions:
No, Ratzinger was not a Nazi sympathizer since he did not voluntarily join the Hitler Youth.
No, being a member of the Nazi party in his youth should not disqualify him, esp since practically he had no choice in the matter.
