The free will theodicy fails biblically

Argue for and against Christianity

Moderator: Moderators

Post Reply
Ray the atheist
Sage
Posts: 678
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 75 times

The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #1

Post by Ray the atheist »

Preamble:

I have been trying to get at the foundational claims of Christianity, and started with the Adam and Eve narrative.

After making over a dozen arguments on that topic, I feel that I should take a break and offer something new... And the idea of free will comes up over and over in the arguments from Christians in defence of God's behaviour over what is sometimes called " the fruit incident " or more commonly, "the fall of man".

The free-will theodicy attempts to explain why God permits evil.

It argues God permits evil because humans possess free will and genuine choices require the possibility of wrongdoing.
If free will isn't real, then the free will theodicy fails.

I would also add that free will is never mentioned in the bible. If free will is so important to the god as to justify creating and allowing evil in our world, I find that to be a truly troubling omission.
The bible doesn't once mention such an important concept, and in fact, shows that the God actually violates people's will.. that's the opposite of promoting free will....
I am using the libertarian idea of free will because thats the kind Christians use:

Libertarian free will is the ability to choose between alternatives such that the choice is not entirely determined by prior causes or conditions.


The Bible portrays God hardening hearts, determining events, and fulfilling purposes, undermining the claim that libertarian free will is essential to God’s plan.
If you need bible references for those claims, just ask. I don't add them all here because the list is too long. Please, don't ask me to list them all in one shot. Just ask when it's relevant to your argument.

The Argument:

P1: The Bible never explicitly establishes libertarian free will as a necessary feature of human agency.
P2: The Bible repeatedly portrays God hardening hearts and determining human actions.
P3: Christian free-will theodicy depends on libertarian free will to explain why God permits evil.
C: Therefore, Christian free-will theodicy fails biblically.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

User avatar
1213
Savant
Posts: 13811
Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 11:06 am
Location: Finland
Has thanked: 555 times
Been thanked: 530 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #2

Post by 1213 »

Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 11:48 am ...It argues God permits evil because humans possess free will and genuine choices require the possibility of wrongdoing.
If free will isn't real, then the free will theodicy fails....
We have free will, so clearly, it is something God wanted us to have. And it means, we can want freely whatever we want. It does not mean things will also necessarily go as we want.

But I think free will is not the right answer to why we can experience evil. The real reason is that people wanted to know evil like God knows, and therefore people were expelled to this “Matrix” where we can experience what evil means.
Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 11:48 amP2: The Bible repeatedly portrays God hardening hearts and determining human actions.
The Bible never explicitly says God determines the actions of humans, or that what humans did, was not their free will choice.
My new book can be read freely from here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rIkqxC ... xtqFY/view

Old version can be read from here:
http://web.archive.org/web/202212010403 ... x_eng.html

Ray the atheist
Sage
Posts: 678
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 75 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #3

Post by Ray the atheist »

[Replying to 1213 in post #2]

Me: ...It argues God permits evil because humans possess free will and genuine choices require the possibility of wrongdoing.
If free will isn't real, then the free will theodicy fails....

You: We have free will, so clearly, it is something God wanted us to have. And it means, we can want freely whatever we want. It does not mean things will also necessarily go as we want.

In order for your argument to work, I would have to assume that free will is real.

I don't, so you would have to persuade me of that.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

Ray the atheist
Sage
Posts: 678
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 75 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #4

Post by Ray the atheist »

[Replying to 1213 in post #2]
But I think free will is not the right answer to why we can experience evil. The real reason is that people wanted to know evil like God knows, and therefore people were expelled to this “Matrix” where we can experience what evil means.
You don't agree with the free will theodicy, and neither do I.

It's great that we agree !!

Please supply textual justification for your theodicy.

Thanks
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

Ray the atheist
Sage
Posts: 678
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 75 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #5

Post by Ray the atheist »

[Replying to 1213 in post #2]

Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 11:48 am
Me: P2: The Bible repeatedly portrays God hardening hearts and determining human actions.

You: The Bible never explicitly says God determines the actions of humans, or that what humans did, was not their free will choice.

I disagree.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

User avatar
1213
Savant
Posts: 13811
Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 11:06 am
Location: Finland
Has thanked: 555 times
Been thanked: 530 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #6

Post by 1213 »

Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2026 10:42 am [Replying to 1213 in post #2]

Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 11:48 am
Me: P2: The Bible repeatedly portrays God hardening hearts and determining human actions.

You: The Bible never explicitly says God determines the actions of humans, or that what humans did, was not their free will choice.

I disagree.
If you disagree, please tell, where the Bible explicitly says God determines the actions of humans, or that what humans did, was not their free will choice.
My new book can be read freely from here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rIkqxC ... xtqFY/view

Old version can be read from here:
http://web.archive.org/web/202212010403 ... x_eng.html

Ray the atheist
Sage
Posts: 678
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 75 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #7

Post by Ray the atheist »

[Replying to 1213 in post #6]
Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 11:48 am
Me: P2: The Bible repeatedly portrays God hardening hearts and determining human actions.

You: The Bible never explicitly says God determines the actions of humans, or that what humans did, was not their free will choice.

Me: I disagree.

You: If you disagree, please tell, where the Bible explicitly says God determines the actions of humans, or that what humans did, was not their free will choice.
_______________________________

I was waiting for someone to ask!!

Thanks... I hadn't made an exhaustive list, and I learned a few verses that I had never heard of.

Great question !!



1. Proverbs 16:9

“A man's heart deviseth his way: but the LORD directeth his steps.”

2. Proverbs 16:33

“The lot is cast into the lap; but the whole disposing thereof is of the LORD.”

3. Proverbs 20:24

“Man's goings are of the LORD; how can a man then understand his own way?”

4. Jeremiah 10:23

“O LORD, I know that the way of man is not in himself: it is not in man that walketh to direct his steps.”

5. Philippians 2:13

“For it is God which worketh in you both to will and to do of his good pleasure.”

6. Proverbs 21:1

“The king's heart is in the hand of the LORD, as the rivers of water: he turneth it whithersoever he will.”

7. Exodus 7:3

“And I will harden Pharaoh's heart, and multiply my signs and my wonders in the land of Egypt.”

8. Exodus 9:12

“And the LORD hardened the heart of Pharaoh, and he hearkened not unto them; as the LORD had spoken unto Moses.”

9. Exodus 10:1

“And the LORD said unto Moses, Go in unto Pharaoh: for I have hardened his heart, and the heart of his servants, that I might shew these my signs before him.”

10. Deuteronomy 2:30

“But Sihon king of Heshbon would not let us pass by him: for the LORD thy God hardened his spirit, and made his heart obstinate, that he might deliver him into thy hand, as appeareth this day.”

11. Joshua 11:20

“For it was of the LORD to harden their hearts, that they should come against Israel in battle, that he might destroy them utterly, and that they might have no favour, but that he might destroy them, as the LORD commanded Moses.”

12. Romans 9:18

“Therefore hath he mercy on whom he will have mercy, and whom he will he hardeneth.”

13. John 12:40

“He hath blinded their eyes, and hardened their heart; that they should not see with their eyes, nor understand with their heart, and be converted, and I should heal them.”

14. Romans 11:8

“(According as it is written, God hath given them the spirit of slumber, eyes that they should not see, and ears that they should not hear;) unto this day.”

15. Genesis 45:7–8

“And God sent me before you to preserve you a posterity in the earth, and to save your lives by a great deliverance.

So now it was not you that sent me hither, but God: and he hath made me a father to Pharaoh, and lord of all his house, and a ruler throughout all the land of Egypt.”

16. Genesis 50:20

“But as for you, ye thought evil against me; but God meant it unto good, to bring to pass, as it is this day, to save much people alive.”

17. 1 Kings 12:15

“Wherefore the king hearkened not unto the people; for the cause was from the LORD, that he might perform his saying, which the LORD spake by Ahijah the Shilonite unto Jeroboam the son of Nebat.”

18. 2 Samuel 24:1

“And again the anger of the LORD was kindled against Israel, and he moved David against them to say, Go, number Israel and Judah.”

19. Isaiah 10:5–7

“O Assyrian, the rod of mine anger, and the staff in their hand is mine indignation.

I will send him against an hypocritical nation, and against the people of my wrath will I give him a charge, to take the spoil, and to take the prey, and to tread them down like the mire of the streets.

Howbeit he meaneth not so, neither doth his heart think so; but it is in his heart to destroy and cut off nations not a few.”

20. Ezekiel 14:9

“And if the prophet be deceived when he hath spoken a thing, I the LORD have deceived that prophet, and I will stretch out my hand upon him, and will destroy him from the midst of my people Israel.”

21. 1 Samuel 16:14

“But the Spirit of the LORD departed from Saul, and an evil spirit from the LORD troubled him.”

22. 1 Kings 22:23

“Now therefore, behold, the LORD hath put a lying spirit in the mouth of all these thy prophets, and the LORD hath spoken evil concerning thee.”

23. Isaiah 63:17

“O LORD, why hast thou made us to err from thy ways, and hardened our heart from thy fear? Return for thy servants' sake, the tribes of thine inheritance.”

24. Amos 3:6

“Shall a trumpet be blown in the city, and the people not be afraid? shall there be evil in a city, and the LORD hath not done it?”

25. Romans 1:24

“Wherefore God also gave them up to uncleanness through the lusts of their own hearts, to dishonour their own bodies between themselves:”

26. 2 Thessalonians 2:11–12

“And for this cause God shall send them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie:

That they all might be damned who believed not the truth, but had pleasure in unrighteousness.”

27. Acts 2:23

“Him, being delivered by the determinate counsel and foreknowledge of God, ye have taken, and by wicked hands have crucified and slain:”

28. Acts 4:27–28

“For of a truth against thy holy child Jesus, whom thou hast anointed, both Herod, and Pontius Pilate, with the Gentiles, and the people of Israel, were gathered together,

For to do whatsoever thy hand and thy counsel determined before to be done.”

29. Acts 13:48

“And when the Gentiles heard this, they were glad, and glorified the word of the Lord: and as many as were ordained to eternal life believed.”

30. Ephesians 1:11

“In whom also we have obtained an inheritance, being predestinated according to the purpose of him who worketh all things after the counsel of his own will:”

31. Revelation 17:17

“For God hath put in their hearts to fulfil his will, and to agree, and give their kingdom unto the beast, until the words of God shall be fulfilled.”
_________________________________

What I didn't do was to make a list where the bible says that God gives us free will.
Maybe you could supply those.


Thanks
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

User avatar
1213
Savant
Posts: 13811
Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 11:06 am
Location: Finland
Has thanked: 555 times
Been thanked: 530 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #8

Post by 1213 »

Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 5:32 am Thanks... I hadn't made an exhaustive list, and I learned a few verses that I had never heard of.
Thanks, but I asked "...explicitly...". Not your interpretation. None of the scriptures explicitly tells God determines the actions, nor that the actions humans make are not by humans’ free will.
Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 5:32 am ...
What I didn't do was to make a list where the bible says that God gives us free will.
Maybe you could supply those.
I don't think it is necessary to say we have free will, when it is obvious otherwise. At least for me, I can want whatever I want freely.
My new book can be read freely from here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rIkqxC ... xtqFY/view

Old version can be read from here:
http://web.archive.org/web/202212010403 ... x_eng.html

Ray the atheist
Sage
Posts: 678
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 75 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #9

Post by Ray the atheist »

[Replying to 1213 in post #8]
Thanks, but I asked "...explicitly...". Not your interpretation. None of the scriptures explicitly tells God determines the actions, nor that the actions humans make are not by humans’ free will.
We can discuss each verse if you like.

But, I suggest that you pick the verse that you think doesn't represent a god who bends the will of a human.

thanks
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

Ray the atheist
Sage
Posts: 678
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 75 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #10

Post by Ray the atheist »

[Replying to 1213 in post #2]
The Bible never explicitly says God determines the actions of humans, or that what humans did, was not their free will choice.
I found over 20 verses that demonstrate otherwise.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

Post Reply