The free will theodicy fails biblically

Argue for and against Christianity

Moderator: Moderators

Post Reply
Ray the atheist
Sage
Posts: 678
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 75 times

The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #1

Post by Ray the atheist »

Preamble:

I have been trying to get at the foundational claims of Christianity, and started with the Adam and Eve narrative.

After making over a dozen arguments on that topic, I feel that I should take a break and offer something new... And the idea of free will comes up over and over in the arguments from Christians in defence of God's behaviour over what is sometimes called " the fruit incident " or more commonly, "the fall of man".

The free-will theodicy attempts to explain why God permits evil.

It argues God permits evil because humans possess free will and genuine choices require the possibility of wrongdoing.
If free will isn't real, then the free will theodicy fails.

I would also add that free will is never mentioned in the bible. If free will is so important to the god as to justify creating and allowing evil in our world, I find that to be a truly troubling omission.
The bible doesn't once mention such an important concept, and in fact, shows that the God actually violates people's will.. that's the opposite of promoting free will....
I am using the libertarian idea of free will because thats the kind Christians use:

Libertarian free will is the ability to choose between alternatives such that the choice is not entirely determined by prior causes or conditions.


The Bible portrays God hardening hearts, determining events, and fulfilling purposes, undermining the claim that libertarian free will is essential to God’s plan.
If you need bible references for those claims, just ask. I don't add them all here because the list is too long. Please, don't ask me to list them all in one shot. Just ask when it's relevant to your argument.

The Argument:

P1: The Bible never explicitly establishes libertarian free will as a necessary feature of human agency.
P2: The Bible repeatedly portrays God hardening hearts and determining human actions.
P3: Christian free-will theodicy depends on libertarian free will to explain why God permits evil.
C: Therefore, Christian free-will theodicy fails biblically.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

User avatar
Clownboat
Savant
Posts: 10487
Joined: Fri Aug 29, 2008 3:42 pm
Has thanked: 1558 times
Been thanked: 1835 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #61

Post by Clownboat »

tam wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:46 pm God is responsible for creating life. He knew evil (sin and death) would end up entering the world and existing for a time, but He also knew that it would be overcome.

An eternity of life, love, good. A short time (especially relative to eternity), wherein sin and death reign.
I would forgo existence if it meant that billions of souls suffering for eternity in hell wouldn't have to face such eternal torment. Where is your heart in this matter? Would you forgo existence to save billions from eternal torment?
You can give a man a fish and he will be fed for a day, or you can teach a man to pray for fish and he will starve to death.

I blame man for codifying those rules into a book which allowed superstitious people to perpetuate a barbaric practice. Rules that must be followed or face an invisible beings wrath. - KenRU

It is sad that in an age of freedom some people are enslaved by the nomads of old. - Marco

If you are unable to demonstrate that what you believe is true and you absolve yourself of the burden of proof, then what is the purpose of your arguments? - brunumb

AchillesHeel
Apprentice
Posts: 115
Joined: Fri Sep 08, 2023 6:02 pm
Has thanked: 7 times
Been thanked: 98 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #62

Post by AchillesHeel »

tam wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:46 pm Peace to you,

What does that have to do with anything?
You're speaking after the fact of existing and having an emotional attachment to that experience. So none of that is relevant when we are assessing a state of affairs where humans simply do not exist.
God is responsible for creating life. He knew evil (sin and death) would end up entering the world and existing for a time, but He also knew that it would be overcome.

An eternity of life, love, good. A short time (especially relative to eternity), wherein sin and death reign.
God could have just created heaven with everyone in it from the start, making sin and evil unnecessary.

AchillesHeel
Apprentice
Posts: 115
Joined: Fri Sep 08, 2023 6:02 pm
Has thanked: 7 times
Been thanked: 98 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #63

Post by AchillesHeel »

1213 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 12:40 am That actions are foreknown doesn't mean humans don't choose freely their own actions.
The point is those actions are destined to take place once the person is created. How do you square destiny/inevitability with "freely choosing their own actions?"

Remember, humans don't "freely choose" to exist under this type of belief. That decision is made for them.

Online
User avatar
tam
Savant
Posts: 7081
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2015 4:59 pm
Has thanked: 408 times
Been thanked: 376 times
Contact:

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #64

Post by tam »

Peace to you Clownboat,
Clownboat wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 12:06 pm
tam wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:46 pm God is responsible for creating life. He knew evil (sin and death) would end up entering the world and existing for a time, but He also knew that it would be overcome.

An eternity of life, love, good. A short time (especially relative to eternity), wherein sin and death reign.
I would forgo existence if it meant that billions of souls suffering for eternity in hell wouldn't have to face such eternal torment.


But there is no such thing as eternal suffering in hell.

That is one of the many lies told by religion about God.

Eternal Hell: Yes or No - viewtopic.php?p=1028604#p1028604


Peace again.
- Non-religious Christian spirituality

- For Christ (who is the Spirit)

User avatar
Clownboat
Savant
Posts: 10487
Joined: Fri Aug 29, 2008 3:42 pm
Has thanked: 1558 times
Been thanked: 1835 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #65

Post by Clownboat »

tam wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 12:24 pm But there is no such thing as eternal suffering in hell.
Matthew 25:46 – "And these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life.
Matthew 25:41 – "Then he will say to those on his left, 'Depart from me, you cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels."
Revelation 14:11 – "And the smoke of their torment rises for ever and ever. There is no rest day or night for those who worship the beast and his image."
Revelation 20:10 – "And the devil, who deceived them, was thrown into the lake of burning sulfur... They will be tormented day and night for ever and ever."
Mark 9:48 – Where the worm "does not die and the fire is not quenched."
Daniel 12:2 – "Many of those who sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt."
2 Thessalonians 1:9 – "They will suffer the punishment of eternal destruction, away from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his might."
That is one of the many lies told by religion about God.

Eternal Hell: Yes or No - viewtopic.php?p=1028604#p1028604

Peace again.
Thank you for acknowledging that your religion includes lies/deception. I feel you are trying to proliferate one yourself here about hell, or the lack there of.
Every religious claim is a lie or deception though, unless the god concept is true and portrayed accurately. As you admit (one of the many lies), your god concept is therefore disqualified.
You can give a man a fish and he will be fed for a day, or you can teach a man to pray for fish and he will starve to death.

I blame man for codifying those rules into a book which allowed superstitious people to perpetuate a barbaric practice. Rules that must be followed or face an invisible beings wrath. - KenRU

It is sad that in an age of freedom some people are enslaved by the nomads of old. - Marco

If you are unable to demonstrate that what you believe is true and you absolve yourself of the burden of proof, then what is the purpose of your arguments? - brunumb

Online
User avatar
tam
Savant
Posts: 7081
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2015 4:59 pm
Has thanked: 408 times
Been thanked: 376 times
Contact:

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #66

Post by tam »

Peace to you,
Clownboat wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 12:37 pm
tam wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 12:24 pm But there is no such thing as eternal suffering in hell.
Matthew 25:46 – "And these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life.
Matthew 25:41 – "Then he will say to those on his left, 'Depart from me, you cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels."
Revelation 14:11 – "And the smoke of their torment rises for ever and ever. There is no rest day or night for those who worship the beast and his image."
Revelation 20:10 – "And the devil, who deceived them, was thrown into the lake of burning sulfur... They will be tormented day and night for ever and ever."
Mark 9:48 – Where the worm "does not die and the fire is not quenched."
Daniel 12:2 – "Many of those who sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt."
2 Thessalonians 1:9 – "They will suffer the punishment of eternal destruction, away from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his might."
See thread linked below. Many discussion have been had on this topic, and the verses you've chosen above have been addressed on the below thread or one of the threads linked in it.
That is one of the many lies told by religion about God.

Eternal Hell: Yes or No - viewtopic.php?p=1028604#p1028604

Peace again.
**
Thank you for acknowledging that your religion includes lies/deception.
Clownboat, it is not my religion. I do not have a religion. I am not in a religion. So that there is no misunderstanding of what I mean when I say religion - I am speaking of organized institutions and their many sects and denominations.
Every religious claim is a lie or deception though, unless the god concept is true and portrayed accurately. As you admit (one of the many lies), your god concept is therefore disqualified.
But that would be your 'god concept' would it not?

Why do you think religion - an entity that you must believe is wrong - has any idea what it is talking about when it comes to God?


Peace again.
- Non-religious Christian spirituality

- For Christ (who is the Spirit)

User avatar
1213
Savant
Posts: 13811
Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 11:06 am
Location: Finland
Has thanked: 555 times
Been thanked: 530 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #67

Post by 1213 »

AchillesHeel wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 12:13 pm
1213 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 12:40 am That actions are foreknown doesn't mean humans don't choose freely their own actions.
The point is those actions are destined to take place once the person is created. How do you square destiny/inevitability with "freely choosing their own actions?"
The actions are destined by the people who make the choices. Foreknowledge doesn't make the decisions.
My new book can be read freely from here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rIkqxC ... xtqFY/view

Old version can be read from here:
http://web.archive.org/web/202212010403 ... x_eng.html

User avatar
Clownboat
Savant
Posts: 10487
Joined: Fri Aug 29, 2008 3:42 pm
Has thanked: 1558 times
Been thanked: 1835 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #68

Post by Clownboat »

tam wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:11 pm Many discussion have been had on this topic, and the verses you've chosen above have been addressed on the below thread or one of the threads linked in it.
I posted this for the readers. No harm in making the verses available for them to read for themselves to then determine what they feel eternal means when discussing the Biblical concept of hell.
Clownboat, it is not my religion. I do not have a religion.

Readers, decide for yourself if Tam has religious beliefs.
religion
noun
1 : an organized system of religious attitudes, beliefs, and practices
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/religion
I am speaking of organized institutions and their many sects and denominations.
Then you don't seem to be speaking about religion. The definition doesn't include institutions.
I get it. As a former Christian myself, I also denied being a part of a religion. In place of that I claimed I was in a relationship. This made me feel different from all those religious people. In reality, we both were/are part of a system of religious attitudes, beliefs and practices, even though neither of us wants(ed) to admit it.
Every religious claim is a lie or deception though, unless the god concept is true and portrayed accurately. As you admit (one of the many lies), your god concept is therefore disqualified.
But that would be your 'god concept' would it not?
No, it was your cliam: "That is one of the many lies told by religion about God." (You were speaking about your God).
Why do you think religion - an entity that you must believe is wrong - has any idea what it is talking about when it comes to God?
Thanks for asking. I don't think a religion exists that knows a single thing about any god concept, but I'm open to being wrong about this.
You can give a man a fish and he will be fed for a day, or you can teach a man to pray for fish and he will starve to death.

I blame man for codifying those rules into a book which allowed superstitious people to perpetuate a barbaric practice. Rules that must be followed or face an invisible beings wrath. - KenRU

It is sad that in an age of freedom some people are enslaved by the nomads of old. - Marco

If you are unable to demonstrate that what you believe is true and you absolve yourself of the burden of proof, then what is the purpose of your arguments? - brunumb

User avatar
Clownboat
Savant
Posts: 10487
Joined: Fri Aug 29, 2008 3:42 pm
Has thanked: 1558 times
Been thanked: 1835 times

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #69

Post by Clownboat »

1213 wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:17 am The actions are destined by the people who make the choices. Foreknowledge doesn't make the decisions.
Let's test this shall we?

Imagine that your god concept create a person called 1234. With their all knowing creating powers, when they create this person who they knew would be born in Iraq, they create them knowing full well that they will be born into a loving Muslim family and will be raised as a Muslim.
Your god concept didn't create this person wondering what god concept they would choose to follow. It created them knowing that they would be one of billions of Muslims.

Do you argue that 1234 had free will to go against what your God knew would happen upon their creation? Or did 1234 fulfill what your God knew would take place?
You can give a man a fish and he will be fed for a day, or you can teach a man to pray for fish and he will starve to death.

I blame man for codifying those rules into a book which allowed superstitious people to perpetuate a barbaric practice. Rules that must be followed or face an invisible beings wrath. - KenRU

It is sad that in an age of freedom some people are enslaved by the nomads of old. - Marco

If you are unable to demonstrate that what you believe is true and you absolve yourself of the burden of proof, then what is the purpose of your arguments? - brunumb

Online
User avatar
tam
Savant
Posts: 7081
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2015 4:59 pm
Has thanked: 408 times
Been thanked: 376 times
Contact:

Re: The free will theodicy fails biblically

Post #70

Post by tam »

Peace again,
Clownboat wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 10:33 am
tam wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:11 pm Many discussion have been had on this topic, and the verses you've chosen above have been addressed on the below thread or one of the threads linked in it.
I posted this for the readers. No harm in making the verses available for them to read for themselves to then determine what they feel eternal means when discussing the Biblical concept of hell.
I posted for you and for the reader. Anyone can take a handful of verses and make it seem like they are saying something that they are not. Hence the link to one of many discussions on the topic. It even links to other discussions on the same topic.

viewtopic.php?f=8&t=37975

I do not wish the point to be lost though. On the basis of your belief that (the bible? religion?) teaches eternal suffering in hell, you objected to this:

God is responsible for creating life. He knew evil (sin and death) would end up entering the world and existing for a time, but He also knew that it would be overcome. An eternity of life, love, good. A short time (especially relative to eternity), wherein sin and death reign.


You can of course bring your objection to someone else, someone who does believe in eternal suffering in hell for billions of people. But it has nothing to do with my post, my faith, my God.

Clownboat, it is not my religion. I do not have a religion.

Readers, decide for yourself if Tam has religious beliefs.
religion
noun
1 : an organized system of religious attitudes, beliefs, and practices
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/religion
I am speaking of organized institutions and their many sects and denominations.
Then you don't seem to be speaking about religion. The definition doesn't include institutions.
Well I would question what you think is meant by 'an organized system', Clownboat.

But since I explained what I meant, there should be no need. I could pull a dictionary definition as well, but many on this forum would object:

Atheism: the belief that God does not exist

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictio ... sh/atheism
Every religious claim is a lie or deception though, unless the god concept is true and portrayed accurately. As you admit (one of the many lies), your god concept is therefore disqualified.
But that would be your 'god concept' would it not?
No, it was your cliam: "That is one of the many lies told by religion about God." (You were speaking about your God).
So then were you attempting to suggest that if "person a" lies about "person b" then "person b" does not exist?

Why do you think religion - an entity that you must believe is wrong - has any idea what it is talking about when it comes to God?
Thanks for asking. I don't think a religion exists that knows a single thing about any god concept, but I'm open to being wrong about this.
Then why do you believe that religion is correct that God (the Father of Christ) will send billions of people to hell to suffer for all eternity? Why do you accept and promote their interpretation or understanding?


Peace again.
- Non-religious Christian spirituality

- For Christ (who is the Spirit)

Post Reply