Can Atheism ground objective morality?

For the love of the pursuit of knowledge

Moderator: Moderators

Post Reply
User avatar
The Tanager
Savant
Posts: 6344
Joined: Wed May 06, 2015 11:08 am
Has thanked: 97 times
Been thanked: 284 times

Can Atheism ground objective morality?

Post #1

Post by The Tanager »

In my exploration and discussions, I have not seen an atheistic worldview be able to logically account for morality being objective. The closest I've seen is an atheistic platonic kind of moral system, but while that seems to be able to account for the existence of 'good' and 'evil', it still doesn't seem to account for why humans would be obligated to choose Good over Evil. I'd love to hear cases from those who think atheism can account for objective morality to make sure I haven't missed (or misunderstood) thoughts in my exploration.

User avatar
The Tanager
Savant
Posts: 6344
Joined: Wed May 06, 2015 11:08 am
Has thanked: 97 times
Been thanked: 284 times

Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?

Post #171

Post by The Tanager »

[Replying to Ray the atheist in post #170]
Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 10:17 pmJust to be clear, I think we are talking about reality and our opinions about that reality.
We can share our opinions about (a) the nature of reality and (b) us having opinions about the nature of reality. The objectivist/subjectivist issue is about (a).

You didn't respond to the questions at the end of my last post, which can move that discussion forward.

"Okay, but how do we decide something counts as a (tentative) fact? Is it only through evidence gathered through our senses or reliable instruments? If so, why? If not, what else can lead us to facts about reality and why?"

User avatar
AgnosticBoy
Guru
Posts: 1687
Joined: Mon Oct 09, 2017 1:44 pm
Has thanked: 216 times
Been thanked: 173 times
Contact:

Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?

Post #172

Post by AgnosticBoy »

The Tanager wrote: ↑Thu Feb 29, 2024 1:02 pm In my exploration and discussions, I have not seen an atheistic worldview be able to logically account for morality being objective. The closest I've seen is an atheistic platonic kind of moral system, but while that seems to be able to account for the existence of 'good' and 'evil', it still doesn't seem to account for why humans would be obligated to choose Good over Evil.
Agreed. It doesn't account for oughtness. It also doesn't provide an objective moral epistemology.

We can all come up with moral values, but how can we know which ones are really good or bad? We'd need an objective way of getting to that.

In the past, someone told me it is whatever enables us to survive (natural selection?). But then I question that seeing that plenty of societies have survived a long time and we can't really nail down that it was because of this or that, especially when there's a mix of different values. The US is so diverse in values, I couldn't tell you anymore which ones matter other than the major ones, don't kill, steal, etc.
- Blogger The Agnostic Blog

- As a non-partisan, I like to be on the side of truth. - AB

User avatar
William
Savant
Posts: 16499
Joined: Tue Jul 31, 2012 8:11 pm
Location: Te Waipounamu
Has thanked: 1038 times
Been thanked: 1951 times
Contact:

Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?

Post #173

Post by William »

The Tanager wrote: ↑Thu Feb 29, 2024 1:02 pm In my exploration and discussions, I have not seen an atheistic worldview be able to logically account for morality being objective. The closest I've seen is an atheistic platonic kind of moral system, but while that seems to be able to account for the existence of 'good' and 'evil', it still doesn't seem to account for why humans would be obligated to choose Good over Evil. I'd love to hear cases from those who think atheism can account for objective morality to make sure I haven't missed (or misunderstood) thoughts in my exploration.
How does theism "account" for this supposed "objective morality"?
Image

The question has never been whether God is speaking. The question has always been whether there is anyone listening - anyone who has stopped hiding long enough to hear.

User avatar
William
Savant
Posts: 16499
Joined: Tue Jul 31, 2012 8:11 pm
Location: Te Waipounamu
Has thanked: 1038 times
Been thanked: 1951 times
Contact:

Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?

Post #174

Post by William »

I have seen no arguments from atheism which account for a supposed "objective morality". Perhaps this is because no such thing exists so there is nothing to account for.

There is of course the possibility that good and evil were not meant to be part of human thinking...re the forbidden fruit story...perhaps because of the very dilemma which comes from such thinking.

Reading the Eden story as a warning against moral judgment itself flips traditional theology on its head, framing "good and evil" not as divine laws we broke, but as a divisive mental trap we were warned not to fall into. In this view, eating from the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil was the exact moment humans invented the painful illusion of objective moral categories.

"Life as it is" is not built on kindness, fairness, or respect for autonomy. It is built on biological consumption and random suffering.

The argument that a "paradise without suffering" existed pre "the fall" may not mean at all that suffering wasn't present but that the capacity to view something as suffering was absent in the pre-fall human condition.

For a lion, a spider, or a human to stay alive, another living organism must be destroyed and consumed. Suffering and death are not bugs in the system; they are the primary fuel of the ecosystem. The way they were designed and apparently "good" in the eyes of the designers...yet in the same story the designers declare humans now know what the designers know (or think how the designers think) re making moral judgements as to "what is good and evil"...

If "causing unnecessary suffering is objectively wrong," then designing a biological world that requires suffering for survival makes the creator the ultimate violator of any supposed objective morality.

The most common argument to this observation I have noted is that "God" (the designers) having an elevated and far more comprehensive understanding of - lets say - "how things are and how those things should be understood...therefore to "lean on one's own understanding" (as a member of the fallen) one ought NOT presume to understand such things as the designers understand them.

Earthquakes, childhood bone cancer, parasitic wasps, and genetic birth defects happen entirely because of how physics and biology were designed and constructed.

When apologists insist on supposed objective morality to prove God exists, they inadvertently create a standard of goodness that a human mind condemns such designers for building a world full of unavoidable agony.

If a creator species designed a physical universe driven by natural cycles of life, death, and survival, then the introduction of moral judgment into human minds creates an immediate disaster.

Once humans start categorizing events as "good" or "evil," they inevitably look at natural pain, predation, and mortality and judge the creator's world as broken or cruel.

Trying to live by rigid, absolute moral rules inside a biological system that runs on survival instincts sets humans up for endless guilt and hypocrisy. Forbidding (the fruit story) can be understood as a creator trying to spare humans from a cognitive burden their biology isn't designed to bear.

Texts like the Tao Te Ching explicitly argue that concepts of "good" and "evil" are artificial human inventions that pull us away from the natural flow of reality (the Tao). When people stop judging things as good or bad, conflict and suffering drop away.

Nietzsche perhaps argued that dividing the world into "Good and Evil" was a psychological invention that made humans resentful of natural life, strength, and instinct. He urged humanity to move "beyond good and evil" back toward accepting life as it is.

Many mystical traditions view moral dualism as an ego illusion. From a non-dual perspective, reality simply is, and labeling parts of it "evil" is just the human mind projecting its own preferences onto a desinged universe.

Humanity does not actually need objective morality, divine commands, or concepts of "good and evil" to protect children or stop violent offenders. Empathy, parental instinct, and the basic drive for social preservation are already built into human biology - allowing a community to neutralize threats naturally, without ever needing to invent a cosmic moral court.

Which is to say that the invention itself stems from partaking in the "fruit" of supposed "knowledge" of "good and evil". It is neither knowledge (in any true sense) or particularly fruitful (in an objectively historical sense).
Image

The question has never been whether God is speaking. The question has always been whether there is anyone listening - anyone who has stopped hiding long enough to hear.

User avatar
The Tanager
Savant
Posts: 6344
Joined: Wed May 06, 2015 11:08 am
Has thanked: 97 times
Been thanked: 284 times

Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?

Post #175

Post by The Tanager »

William wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 2:56 pmHow does theism "account" for this supposed "objective morality"?
The short answer is that I think theism can provide both an objective nature for the various entities that exist, as well as an objective purpose for some to be moral agents designed to seek the good for those objective natures. I think atheism can account for the objective nature part, but not the objective purpose part.

User avatar
The Tanager
Savant
Posts: 6344
Joined: Wed May 06, 2015 11:08 am
Has thanked: 97 times
Been thanked: 284 times

Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?

Post #176

Post by The Tanager »

William wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 5:01 pmHumanity does not actually need objective morality, divine commands, or concepts of "good and evil" to protect children or stop violent offenders. Empathy, parental instinct, and the basic drive for social preservation are already built into human biology - allowing a community to neutralize threats naturally, without ever needing to invent a cosmic moral court.
There is plenty of questions one could respond to in your post, but I want to focus on this one. I see a contradiction here. You say we don't need concepts of good and evil, but then imply violent offenders are evil and that protecting children and stopping those violent offenders is good. I agree that this is built into us. But I believe that Someone would have had to build that into us as an objective purpose for it to make any sense.

User avatar
William
Savant
Posts: 16499
Joined: Tue Jul 31, 2012 8:11 pm
Location: Te Waipounamu
Has thanked: 1038 times
Been thanked: 1951 times
Contact:

Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?

Post #177

Post by William »

The Tanager wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:43 pm
William wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 2:56 pmHow does theism "account" for this supposed "objective morality"?
The short answer is that I think theism can provide both an objective nature for the various entities that exist,
What is your reason for thinking this? Please provide an example of "an objective nature", and say why it relates to the idea of objective morality/


as well as an objective purpose for some to be moral agents designed to seek the good for those objective natures
I think atheism can account for the objective nature part, but not the objective purpose part.
Why do you think this? How does your thinking this add anything to the idea that objective morality is real?
Image

The question has never been whether God is speaking. The question has always been whether there is anyone listening - anyone who has stopped hiding long enough to hear.

User avatar
William
Savant
Posts: 16499
Joined: Tue Jul 31, 2012 8:11 pm
Location: Te Waipounamu
Has thanked: 1038 times
Been thanked: 1951 times
Contact:

Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?

Post #178

Post by William »

The Tanager wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:49 pm
William wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 5:01 pmHumanity does not actually need objective morality, divine commands, or concepts of "good and evil" to protect children or stop violent offenders. Empathy, parental instinct, and the basic drive for social preservation are already built into human biology - allowing a community to neutralize threats naturally, without ever needing to invent a cosmic moral court.
There is plenty of questions one could respond to in your post, but I want to focus on this one. I see a contradiction here. You say we don't need concepts of good and evil, but then imply violent offenders are evil and that protecting children and stopping those violent offenders is good. I agree that this is built into us. But I believe that Someone would have had to build that into us as an objective purpose for it to make any sense.
Unfortunately "focusing" on just that one part of my post, and through that claiming I "imply" that "violent offenders are evil", is misrepresenting the whole post in context.
Image

The question has never been whether God is speaking. The question has always been whether there is anyone listening - anyone who has stopped hiding long enough to hear.

User avatar
AgnosticBoy
Guru
Posts: 1687
Joined: Mon Oct 09, 2017 1:44 pm
Has thanked: 216 times
Been thanked: 173 times
Contact:

Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?

Post #179

Post by AgnosticBoy »

AgnosticBoy wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 2:12 pm
The Tanager wrote: ↑Thu Feb 29, 2024 1:02 pm In my exploration and discussions, I have not seen an atheistic worldview be able to logically account for morality being objective. The closest I've seen is an atheistic platonic kind of moral system, but while that seems to be able to account for the existence of 'good' and 'evil', it still doesn't seem to account for why humans would be obligated to choose Good over Evil.
Agreed. It doesn't account for oughtness. It also doesn't provide an objective moral epistemology.

We can all come up with moral values, but how can we know which ones are really good or bad? We'd need an objective way of getting to that.

In the past, someone told me it is whatever enables us to survive (natural selection?). But then I question that seeing that plenty of societies have survived a long time and we can't really nail down that it was because of this or that, especially when there's a mix of different values. The US is so diverse in values, I couldn't tell you anymore which ones matter other than the major ones, don't kill, steal, etc.
Actually, I take back the do not kill part. Even those lines are now blurred so it's not that simple. Where it used to be only acceptable to kill out of self-defense, now some are praising the killing of even innocent people.

Some examples are those cheering when the UnitedHealthcare CEO was killed, or when Charlie Kirk was killed (death being justified based on speech you don't like?), or even the death of Jewish babies (some in the the Free Palestine crowd accept). Seems the killing of anyone can be justified if you can manage to put them on the opposing end of any political cause or of any popular social media movement.
- Blogger The Agnostic Blog

- As a non-partisan, I like to be on the side of truth. - AB

Ray the atheist
Sage
Posts: 678
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 75 times

Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?

Post #180

Post by Ray the atheist »

[Replying to The Tanager in post #1]
In my exploration and discussions, I have not seen an atheistic worldview be able to logically account for morality being objective. The closest I've seen is an atheistic platonic kind of moral system, but while that seems to be able to account for the existence of 'good' and 'evil', it still doesn't seem to account for why humans would be obligated to choose Good over Evil. I'd love to hear cases from those who think atheism can account for objective morality to make sure I haven't missed (or misunderstood) thoughts in my exploration.
Im an atheist.

I don't believe in objective morality.

So, you wont getting me to explain how an atheist can believe in objective morality unless we can accept a goal.. Im not sure if your objective morality requires one. We could discuss that.

I am only obligated to choose between good and evil due to the fact that I want to choose the good and shun the evil, and that I live with other people who also shun evil and would have their policemen arrest me for breaking the law.

Most laws are intended to be moral.. and to me, that's an objective fact of life.

So, maybe your quest to find an atheist who does believe in objective morality just wont pan out. I would not hold my breath, as I really do believe that the philosophical jury is out on that one.

But there is hope !!

Several atheist philosophers defend objective morality:

1. Derek Parfit
2. Erik Wielenberg
3. Russ Shafer-Landau
4. G. E. Moore
5. Michael Huemer

And MAYBE me. ( amateur philosopher at your service )

I had thought of way to obtain objective morality but it requires a goal.

If the goal of morality is to enhance human flourishing and diminish human suffering, then there are objective ways to accomplish that goal.

What do you think about that?.. maybe we can flesh out the problem together since you seem to know a thing or two about objective morality and I have a little time on my hands.

let me know

CAVEAT: I could not use God as grounds for any kind of morality since I don't believe in God.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

Post Reply