Can Atheism ground objective morality?
Moderator: Moderators
- The Tanager
- Savant
- Posts: 6346
- Joined: Wed May 06, 2015 11:08 am
- Has thanked: 98 times
- Been thanked: 284 times
Can Atheism ground objective morality?
Post #1In my exploration and discussions, I have not seen an atheistic worldview be able to logically account for morality being objective. The closest I've seen is an atheistic platonic kind of moral system, but while that seems to be able to account for the existence of 'good' and 'evil', it still doesn't seem to account for why humans would be obligated to choose Good over Evil. I'd love to hear cases from those who think atheism can account for objective morality to make sure I haven't missed (or misunderstood) thoughts in my exploration.
- William
- Savant
- Posts: 16504
- Joined: Tue Jul 31, 2012 8:11 pm
- Location: Te Waipounamu
- Has thanked: 1038 times
- Been thanked: 1951 times
- Contact:
Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?
Post #191Tanager - perhaps your OP is best read as an enthymeme, with two unstated premises:
"If atheism can't ground objective morality, then theism is the most plausible ground."
and
"If theism can account for objective morality, then objective morality is evidence for theism."
Both are big "ifs," and I'd like to see them defended rather than assumed.
On your positive account, objective morality is grounded in the natures God gave beings and the purpose he designed them for. But here's the problem: the natures God gave beings include both help and harm - empathy and aggression, cooperation and consumption. So the nature alone doesn't yield a determinate morality; it has to be the purpose that does the work. But the purpose is asserted, not derived from the nature. And an asserted purpose is subjectively sourced - it's posited rather than read off what is. So the grounding collapses into subjectivism at exactly the joint where it needs to be objective.
This matters comparatively. Both theist and atheist can hold and act on moral beliefs; both can bring a sense of ought into the world and try to live by it. The question is what grounds them. The theist grounds them in a particular claim about the designer's nature; the atheist grounds them elsewhere or denies they need a cosmic ground. So the real question is whether the theist's grounding does the work it claims - and the design itself gives reason to doubt that it does.
This is the same structure I see in the Eden story and in the biology. A rule is imposed on a nature that pulls against it; the creature is caught between the rule and the biology; and the dualism of God vs. Devil is the externalized version of that split - the good rule gets a cosmic author, the rebellious impulse gets a cosmic adversary, and the human is the battlefield. But the dualism doesn't resolve the contradiction; it just relocates it. Two entities vying doesn't explain why the nature is split; it just personifies the split.
So the onus is on the theist to state why the designer's nature ought to be as stated...why the purpose is the empathic one rather than the aggressive one, and why an asserted purpose grounds obligation rather than just expressing a preference. The atheist is under no obligation to accept a grounding that hasn't been shown to work, and the design itself gives reason to doubt that it does. As far as I can see, the theistic grounding doesn't account for this. If I'm misunderstanding your position, I'm happy to be corrected.
"If atheism can't ground objective morality, then theism is the most plausible ground."
and
"If theism can account for objective morality, then objective morality is evidence for theism."
Both are big "ifs," and I'd like to see them defended rather than assumed.
On your positive account, objective morality is grounded in the natures God gave beings and the purpose he designed them for. But here's the problem: the natures God gave beings include both help and harm - empathy and aggression, cooperation and consumption. So the nature alone doesn't yield a determinate morality; it has to be the purpose that does the work. But the purpose is asserted, not derived from the nature. And an asserted purpose is subjectively sourced - it's posited rather than read off what is. So the grounding collapses into subjectivism at exactly the joint where it needs to be objective.
This matters comparatively. Both theist and atheist can hold and act on moral beliefs; both can bring a sense of ought into the world and try to live by it. The question is what grounds them. The theist grounds them in a particular claim about the designer's nature; the atheist grounds them elsewhere or denies they need a cosmic ground. So the real question is whether the theist's grounding does the work it claims - and the design itself gives reason to doubt that it does.
This is the same structure I see in the Eden story and in the biology. A rule is imposed on a nature that pulls against it; the creature is caught between the rule and the biology; and the dualism of God vs. Devil is the externalized version of that split - the good rule gets a cosmic author, the rebellious impulse gets a cosmic adversary, and the human is the battlefield. But the dualism doesn't resolve the contradiction; it just relocates it. Two entities vying doesn't explain why the nature is split; it just personifies the split.
So the onus is on the theist to state why the designer's nature ought to be as stated...why the purpose is the empathic one rather than the aggressive one, and why an asserted purpose grounds obligation rather than just expressing a preference. The atheist is under no obligation to accept a grounding that hasn't been shown to work, and the design itself gives reason to doubt that it does. As far as I can see, the theistic grounding doesn't account for this. If I'm misunderstanding your position, I'm happy to be corrected.

The question has never been whether God is speaking. The question has always been whether there is anyone listening - anyone who has stopped hiding long enough to hear.
- The Tanager
- Savant
- Posts: 6346
- Joined: Wed May 06, 2015 11:08 am
- Has thanked: 98 times
- Been thanked: 284 times
Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?
Post #192[Replying to William in post #191]
As to a contradiction, I don’t see how that’s the case at all. Yes, Christians (and others) can be judgmental of others, but that doesn’t mean they have to be or are meant to be.
One could then make further arguments about the truth of objective morality and how that is most plausible on theism being true and, therefore, is a reason to believe in theism, but I haven’t done so here.
Yes, God can bring about beings with objective natures.
Yes, you asked about my theological belief. God could conceivably bring about beings like us that have an objective purpose to seek the objective good of others. This, combined with the objective nature bit, if true, would get us objective morality.William wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:50 pmThat is a theological belief, granted. However, in the real world it becomes a contradiction in the face of the nature of the design. Essentially your "Christian theism" easily bows to the temptation of judgmentalism when the "ought" is declared good and true and that which does not comply become evil and false.
As to a contradiction, I don’t see how that’s the case at all. Yes, Christians (and others) can be judgmental of others, but that doesn’t mean they have to be or are meant to be.
I missed your answer to my question. I’m sorry, but could you repeat that before I answer your question?William wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:50 pmAh the old "abusing a child" argument.
Let me ask you this then. If harm is abuse, and if the designed environment causes harm, then is it abuse to place ANY living being (let alone children) in harm's way? When looking at the possible actions of a designer of such a system (a) abusing a creature or (b) not abusing a creature do you believe one of those is what a designer should do or are these actions equal in value?...
No, I have not argued anything like that.
I’ve argued that objective morality (as a concept) is not just human subjective beliefs and that, if it exists, it seems out of place within atheism being true (not within atheists themselves), while it doesn’t seem out of place within theism being true.
One could then make further arguments about the truth of objective morality and how that is most plausible on theism being true and, therefore, is a reason to believe in theism, but I haven’t done so here.
I’m not sure what you mean here. How is it asserted instead of built into one’s nature? The ontology of it, not human epistemology of it.William wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 2:57 pmSo the nature alone doesn't yield a determinate morality; it has to be the purpose that does the work. But the purpose is asserted, not derived from the nature. And an asserted purpose is subjectively sourced - it's posited rather than read off what is. So the grounding collapses into subjectivism at exactly the joint where it needs to be objective.
Okay, make the argument with the supporting reasons (or restate them more clearly) for the environment not being designed for that purpose and I’ll listen.William wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:50 pmI would argue that this environment (the universe - and specifically our local environment) isn't designed for such a purpose. The question of what OUGHT be done cannot be answered from within said environment either by Christianity or any other theistic collective, any more than it can be answered by any non-theistic collective, because it - the environment - was not designed for that purpose.
- The Tanager
- Savant
- Posts: 6346
- Joined: Wed May 06, 2015 11:08 am
- Has thanked: 98 times
- Been thanked: 284 times
Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?
Post #193[Replying to Ray the atheist in post #190]
I can agree with that (although we may mean different things by the phrase “playing with words”. I was specifically referring to the context of simply changing the definitions of terms to get a certain result.Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:54 pmDisagree.Yeah, in my experience, playing with words never has good results.
Philosophy is only playing with words that represent ideas.
I don’t think that is going beyond our personal preferences. Sharks also have personal preferences that come with being sharks, through their bee DNA. That doesn’t mean that is our objective purpose. If evolution had gone differently, maybe we’d be okay with forcible copulation as well.Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:58 pm1. As I said, I can provide a way to go beyond our personal preferences. For example, I don't recall having consciously preferred pleasure over pain. I think that comes with being human. DNA offers us some objectivity. A base line for all humans, if you will.
Yes, they have the power to enforce the laws. And it’s practical for us to obey them to avoid the “or else”. I think that’s still a choice on our part, not an objective obligation. My point was that laws that go against human flourishing (if there is such an objective reality) could also be made and enforced, so having laws isn’t enough to give us an objective morality.Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:58 pm2. I don't know where you live, but if I break the law and get caught, I will be obligated to pay a fine or have a vacation in jail. Once the laws are established, all citizens in my jurisdiction are obligated by law to follow the law or else.
I don't like the "or else" so I feel obligated to obey.
- William
- Savant
- Posts: 16504
- Joined: Tue Jul 31, 2012 8:11 pm
- Location: Te Waipounamu
- Has thanked: 1038 times
- Been thanked: 1951 times
- Contact:
Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?
Post #194So, not necessarily subjective good natures?The Tanager wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 12:04 am [Replying to William in post #191]
Yes, God can bring about beings with objective natures.
William wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:50 pmThat is a theological belief, granted. However, in the real world it becomes a contradiction in the face of the nature of the design. Essentially your "Christian theism" easily bows to the temptation of judgmentalism when the "ought" is declared good and true and that which does not comply become evil and false.
If true? Thus, perhaps not...Yes, you asked about my theological belief. God could conceivably bring about beings like us that have an objective purpose to seek the objective good of others. This, combined with the objective nature bit, if true, would get us objective morality.
Perhaps you might agree then that the contradiction is caused in part, due to that?As to a contradiction, I don’t see how that’s the case at all. Yes, Christians (and others) can be judgmental of others, but that doesn’t mean they have to be or are meant to be.
William wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:50 pmAh the old "abusing a child" argument.
Let me ask you this then. If harm is abuse, and if the designed environment causes harm, then is it abuse to place ANY living being (let alone children) in harm's way? When looking at the possible actions of a designer of such a system (a) abusing a creature or (b) not abusing a creature do you believe one of those is what a designer should do or are these actions equal in value?...
Yes - your question. "When looking at the possible actions of (a) abusing a child and (b) not abusing the child, do you believe one of those is what a person should do or are these actions equal in value?"I missed your answer to my question. I’m sorry, but could you repeat that before I answer your question?
I think I answered it sufficiently, but here is another way of saying what I have already pointed out.
I don't believe or disbelieve because there appears no reason to do so, and reason not to develop and maintain such belief.
Everyone who brings children in the world contributes to the harm those children will suffer. Harm is part of the design of this human experience and assuming a designer/designers made it the way that it is, then to make a belief based call on that - either way - is, as I have already mapped out in my posts - so if abuse is harm, the design allows for that thus the designer allows for that.
I have no belief about the values of either abusive action or non-abusive action. My subjective understanding is that I prefer to be kind and considerate to children. Do I see "value" in doing so, rather than being abusive towards them? Honestly, value isn't part of my conscious agenda re that choice. I find it hard to comprehend the concept of value in relation to a personal subjective choice NOT to abuse children. There is no "ought" involved. And as I mentioned, I have no use for belief as a means to instigate ought/out-not behaviour.
No, I have not argued anything like that.
What do you understand atheism to be?I’ve argued that objective morality (as a concept) is not just human subjective beliefs and that, if it exists, it seems out of place within atheism being true (not within atheists themselves), while it doesn’t seem out of place within theism being true.
I understand it to be the conviction that we do not exist in a created environment, thus it is not a creation/simulation therefore there is no creator/creators.
I have asked you before, what is "objective morality"? Now you share that it is a "concept". Perhaps you can expand on that for the sake of clarity. I find it difficult to understand what you are getting at without more clarity your end.
Perhaps. I don't put much stock in morality (objective or not) as key evidence of a creator/creators. I think there is ample evidence we exist within a creation/simulation which might bear more fruit as to the nature of said creator/creators than human morality.One could then make further arguments about the truth of objective morality and how that is most plausible on theism being true and, therefore, is a reason to believe in theism, but I haven’t done so here.
William wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 2:57 pmSo the nature alone doesn't yield a determinate morality; it has to be the purpose that does the work. But the purpose is asserted, not derived from the nature. And an asserted purpose is subjectively sourced - it's posited rather than read off what is. So the grounding collapses into subjectivism at exactly the joint where it needs to be objective.
Some assert that morality is built into one's nature. Are you asserting that?I’m not sure what you mean here. How is it asserted instead of built into one’s nature? The ontology of it, not human epistemology of it.
My understanding is that any nature we have may well derive from the nature of the Creator/s. Thus we can understand both extremes (thought of in terms of either "good" of "evil") as tapping into different aspects of an overall nature which the design reflects. While there are extremes (God and Devil) there is also a spectrum of variation in between those extremes.
I tap into an aspect of the spectrum which suits me subjectively. What is this "me" I am referring to? It appears to be "what I am comfortable with for myself". In that, I don't think I am any different from anyone else in that regard - meaning that I think we all (of sound enough mind) do that. Theism and atheism are just venues for those "comforts".
William wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:50 pmI would argue that this environment (the universe - and specifically our local environment) isn't designed for such a purpose. The question of what OUGHT be done cannot be answered from within said environment either by Christianity or any other theistic collective, any more than it can be answered by any non-theistic collective, because it - the environment - was not designed for that purpose.
I think I have done so adequately and built upon these in subsequent posts. If it's not clear at his point, then I can at least try to restate any specific parts you still find hard to understand.Okay, make the argument with the supporting reasons (or restate them more clearly) for the environment not being designed for that purpose and I’ll listen.
I am not really arguing for or against your own position, because you have yet to clarify what it is you are meaning so perhaps as you do, we can take this forward incrementally.
As to the OUGHT re the environment. What ought one do depends on what the environment plus ones subjective inclinations dictate. Ought is a type of dictation. It also tempts the one adhering to such thinking that what they think they ought do, they believe others ought do as well. However the design doesn't accommodate oughts, as far as I have so far observed. Some oughts are contradictory to other oughts, depending on what each subjective personality may prefer to listen to/deem not worth listening to. The design doesn't accommodate oughts in the sense that it doesn't provide a stable, conflict-free standard for them.
The environment is not designed to be static so any oughts require movement aligned with the environment, so what one ought do in one moment might not be what one ought do in another.
In other words, there are no hard and fast rules re what ought be done no matter the circumstance, although if you were to argue that humans have tried to implement such rules, I agree that they have but not that they have succeeded. From time to time they may even work for a while and seem successful but the nature of the design appears to have a built in mechanism for upsetting apple-carts.
Those are my thoughts - not my oughts.

The question has never been whether God is speaking. The question has always been whether there is anyone listening - anyone who has stopped hiding long enough to hear.
- William
- Savant
- Posts: 16504
- Joined: Tue Jul 31, 2012 8:11 pm
- Location: Te Waipounamu
- Has thanked: 1038 times
- Been thanked: 1951 times
- Contact:
Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?
Post #195[Replying to The Tanager in post #193]
I tend to ask myself "is the definition true to the thing being described?" rather than "if I accept the definition regardless, will it secure my position in my group?" That's not always easy to answer, because the thing being described may itself be contested - but the question is better than the alternative, which is whether the definition serves the group.
Some definitions have to be tweaked or perhaps even rewritten due to the nature of the human experience - we don't know everything and are still learning...
The point about definitions bears directly on the objective-morality issue: the definitions of "objective," "moral," "ground," and "ought" are perhaps all contestable, and the question of whether a definition is true to the thing is worth being pressed if we want to listen and understand various subjective points of view.
This is why I keep asking what 'objective morality' means - not to be difficult, but because the definition determines what would count as a successful grounding, and a definition chosen for group-convenience may not be true to the thing.
So far (correct me if I am misunderstanding) objective morality has been somewhat defined as "God could conceivably bring about beings like us that have an objective purpose to seek the objective good of others. This, combined with the objective nature bit, if true, would get us objective morality." But is that a true definition? I don't think so, because "God" hasn't been adequately defined in this case and seems to presume a wholly benevolent entity. That contradicts the observable design of the creation, which is not wholly benevolent. So the language appears to require being true to what is observed before any adequate definition can be established.
Yeah, in my experience, playing with words never has good results.
Disagree.
Philosophy is only playing with words that represent ideas.
I think I have to be careful with definitions presented and established as language has a very influential effect on humans and I think it wise to consider some definitions are possibly and even probably thought up to get that certain result and have been academically institutionalised - naturally enough to some extent so that philosophers (for example) can understand one another and can sort themselves into agreeable groups with that in mind. Sometimes the definition that secures your position is also the true one - but the two questions are different, and it's worth asking which one you're actually answering.I can agree with that (although we may mean different things by the phrase “playing with words”. I was specifically referring to the context of simply changing the definitions of terms to get a certain result.
I tend to ask myself "is the definition true to the thing being described?" rather than "if I accept the definition regardless, will it secure my position in my group?" That's not always easy to answer, because the thing being described may itself be contested - but the question is better than the alternative, which is whether the definition serves the group.
Some definitions have to be tweaked or perhaps even rewritten due to the nature of the human experience - we don't know everything and are still learning...
The point about definitions bears directly on the objective-morality issue: the definitions of "objective," "moral," "ground," and "ought" are perhaps all contestable, and the question of whether a definition is true to the thing is worth being pressed if we want to listen and understand various subjective points of view.
This is why I keep asking what 'objective morality' means - not to be difficult, but because the definition determines what would count as a successful grounding, and a definition chosen for group-convenience may not be true to the thing.
So far (correct me if I am misunderstanding) objective morality has been somewhat defined as "God could conceivably bring about beings like us that have an objective purpose to seek the objective good of others. This, combined with the objective nature bit, if true, would get us objective morality." But is that a true definition? I don't think so, because "God" hasn't been adequately defined in this case and seems to presume a wholly benevolent entity. That contradicts the observable design of the creation, which is not wholly benevolent. So the language appears to require being true to what is observed before any adequate definition can be established.

The question has never been whether God is speaking. The question has always been whether there is anyone listening - anyone who has stopped hiding long enough to hear.
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 682
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 76 times
Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?
Post #196[Replying to The Tanager in post #193]
Me: Philosophy is only playing with words that represent ideas.
You: I can agree with that (although we may mean different things by the phrase “playing with words”. I was specifically referring to the context of simply changing the definitions of terms to get a certain result.
________________________
Right.
First off, when I read my comment, it seems silly this morning.
I was tired when I wrote that and used the word playing more poetically that I had to.
What I meant is that philosophy allows me to examine, clarify, and sometimes redefine familiar words or introduce new terms to express ideas more precisely.
That's not playing word games or manipulating definitions.
It's part of philosophy's job to define concepts, clarify their meaning, and explore their logical implications. Words represent ideas, and philosophy examines the ideas those words communicate.
I hope that clarifies my poetic use of "playing with words" in philosophy.
I've noticed that my writing gets sloppy as I get more and more tired.
Sometimes, these kinds of discussions are like chips.. I can't have just one.. I sometimes need to eat the whole family sized bag.
Me: Philosophy is only playing with words that represent ideas.
You: I can agree with that (although we may mean different things by the phrase “playing with words”. I was specifically referring to the context of simply changing the definitions of terms to get a certain result.
________________________
Right.
First off, when I read my comment, it seems silly this morning.
I was tired when I wrote that and used the word playing more poetically that I had to.
What I meant is that philosophy allows me to examine, clarify, and sometimes redefine familiar words or introduce new terms to express ideas more precisely.
That's not playing word games or manipulating definitions.
It's part of philosophy's job to define concepts, clarify their meaning, and explore their logical implications. Words represent ideas, and philosophy examines the ideas those words communicate.
I hope that clarifies my poetic use of "playing with words" in philosophy.
I've noticed that my writing gets sloppy as I get more and more tired.
Sometimes, these kinds of discussions are like chips.. I can't have just one.. I sometimes need to eat the whole family sized bag.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 682
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 76 times
Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?
Post #197[Replying to The Tanager in post #193]
Sharks are amazing creatures and we can surely learn a lot by studying them.
Sharks and dolphins display social behaviours that resemble morality, including cooperation and helping others. However, these behaviours don't establish moral reasoning or moral judgment. We might call this proto-morality, largely driven by biological instincts.
Fish and aquatic mammals are driven by their instincts.
Humans can go beyond their instincts.
Humans also inherit biological instincts, but our neuroplasticity allows us to learn, reconsider beliefs, and change our behaviour.
My own history illustrates this. I began debating Christians online in the early 1990s through Ottawa's National Capital FreeNet. Back then, I mostly attacked people's character, imitated other debaters, and lacked the skills to construct proper arguments.
I was thinking that insults were the "game", and that I should win that game. I felt morally justified in attacking people's characters.
In 2009, I began studying philosophy online. Since then, I've learned to examine ideas, construct arguments, and approach disagreements differently.
I have, in my opinion, made significant progress in my moral judgment.
Unlike sharks, humans can deliberately examine and reshape many of their inherited behavioural tendencies through learning and reflection. We aren't born as blank slates, but neither are we prisoners of our instincts.
But we humans DO come pre-wired with basic moral instincts.
Cool !!Me: 1. As I said, I can provide a way to go beyond our personal preferences. For example, I don't recall having consciously preferred pleasure over pain. I think that comes with being human. DNA offers us some objectivity. A base line for all humans, if you will.
You: I don’t think that is going beyond our personal preferences. Sharks also have personal preferences that come with being sharks, through their bee DNA. That doesn’t mean that is our objective purpose. If evolution had gone differently, maybe we’d be okay with forcible copulation as well.
Sharks are amazing creatures and we can surely learn a lot by studying them.
Sharks and dolphins display social behaviours that resemble morality, including cooperation and helping others. However, these behaviours don't establish moral reasoning or moral judgment. We might call this proto-morality, largely driven by biological instincts.
Fish and aquatic mammals are driven by their instincts.
Humans can go beyond their instincts.
Humans also inherit biological instincts, but our neuroplasticity allows us to learn, reconsider beliefs, and change our behaviour.
My own history illustrates this. I began debating Christians online in the early 1990s through Ottawa's National Capital FreeNet. Back then, I mostly attacked people's character, imitated other debaters, and lacked the skills to construct proper arguments.
I was thinking that insults were the "game", and that I should win that game. I felt morally justified in attacking people's characters.
In 2009, I began studying philosophy online. Since then, I've learned to examine ideas, construct arguments, and approach disagreements differently.
I have, in my opinion, made significant progress in my moral judgment.
Unlike sharks, humans can deliberately examine and reshape many of their inherited behavioural tendencies through learning and reflection. We aren't born as blank slates, but neither are we prisoners of our instincts.
But we humans DO come pre-wired with basic moral instincts.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 682
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 76 times
Re: Can Atheism ground objective morality?
Post #198[Replying to The Tanager in post #193]
Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:58 pm
I agree that obeying the laws to prevent the punishment is a choice that I make.
To me, choices also require choices and so on like in Russian nested dolls...
That legal choice is guided by my natural pain avoidance instinct over which, I HAVE no choice. I can possibly choose to suffer pain in the form of fines or jail, but that takes effort on my part.. Accepting pain isn't natural to me.
I'm switching example from law to medicine:
So, when I go for a medical procedure that I know will hurt a lot, im not happy even if I decide that it's better for my health.
My desire to stay alive and be healthy over-rides my desire to not feel any pain at all.
It gets harder and harder for me to justify my desire to stay alive and be healthy.
I've had multiple medical interventions that hurt me a LOT.
I had to over-ride my need for no suffering.. and obeyed my need to stay alive and be healthy.
I had no choice in the matter.. I have a basic, foundational need to stay alive and be healthy that seems to always over-ride my need to avoid suffering.
I don't know where I have the choice when it comes to medical procedures..
Lets say I want do die.. well, that would be due to a giving up hope.. which I would not have much choice about. Having suffered from a lack of hope in my life, I know how hard it can be to change that.. It can take years of psychotherapy and drugs.
Where is my choice in all of that?... I don't see any.
Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:58 pm
Me: 2. I don't know where you live, but if I break the law and get caught, I will be obligated to pay a fine or have a vacation in jail. Once the laws are established, all citizens in my jurisdiction are obligated by law to follow the law or else.
I don't like the "or else" so I feel obligated to obey.
You: Yes, they have the power to enforce the laws. And it’s practical for us to obey them to avoid the “or else”. I think that’s still a choice on our part, not an objective obligation. My point was that laws that go against human flourishing (if there is such an objective reality) could also be made and enforced, so having laws isn’t enough to give us an objective morality.
I agree that obeying the laws to prevent the punishment is a choice that I make.
To me, choices also require choices and so on like in Russian nested dolls...
That legal choice is guided by my natural pain avoidance instinct over which, I HAVE no choice. I can possibly choose to suffer pain in the form of fines or jail, but that takes effort on my part.. Accepting pain isn't natural to me.
I'm switching example from law to medicine:
So, when I go for a medical procedure that I know will hurt a lot, im not happy even if I decide that it's better for my health.
My desire to stay alive and be healthy over-rides my desire to not feel any pain at all.
It gets harder and harder for me to justify my desire to stay alive and be healthy.
I've had multiple medical interventions that hurt me a LOT.
I had to over-ride my need for no suffering.. and obeyed my need to stay alive and be healthy.
I had no choice in the matter.. I have a basic, foundational need to stay alive and be healthy that seems to always over-ride my need to avoid suffering.
I don't know where I have the choice when it comes to medical procedures..
Lets say I want do die.. well, that would be due to a giving up hope.. which I would not have much choice about. Having suffered from a lack of hope in my life, I know how hard it can be to change that.. It can take years of psychotherapy and drugs.
Where is my choice in all of that?... I don't see any.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

