can you be Christian and bI?
Moderator: Moderators
- rapture101
- Student
- Posts: 79
- Joined: Sat Apr 30, 2005 7:30 pm
- Location: Ameila Island
can you be Christian and bI?
Post #1i know this sounds weird.One of the people I go to school with asked me this questian.So I became a little weird about it.I couldnt find the amswer.So what are your oppions?
- methylatedghosts
- Sage
- Posts: 516
- Joined: Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:21 pm
- Location: Dunedin, New Zealand
Post #51
I have read the bible, and found for myself, that although some things in it may have happened, it isn't all truth as far as I can see.topaz wrote:I dont make the Law. I obey no matter how hard it may be for my own good. There is no way anyone can circumvent or oppose Gods Law yet remain in His kingdom. Why delude yourself? Read the bible and find out if what I am saying is the truth.
How in the world is allowing equality for all people, regardless of sexual orientation backwards?I disagree. In reality, youre backward not progressive.methylatedghosts wrote: In reality, I think we are much further ahead than you in the tolerance of other people and their sexual orientations.
How about having sex with animals? Is this also ok? How about asking your govt. to legalise this too?
Sex with animals is different, it is engaging in sexual acts with members of different species. How many animals do you see doing that? You DO see some species doing homosexual activities though, so why is it so unnatural for humans?
I don't see this as destroying this country, it is welcoming people regardless of who they are and choose to be regarding sex and prostitution.A persons sexual orientation is his own business, they say. How I wish this was so. The bible says that the sins of a people desolate their land, destroy their country.methylatedghosts wrote: What does it matter whether someone is gay or not? God's system is very simple to go with. Experience, experience, experience.
Do you care whether your next door neighbour is gay or not?
I still don't see how your neighbour being gay can affect you in any way. Just because he or she is gay doesn't mean he's out to target you. How will YOU suffer for it? Someone being gay is not against the "good of society". Gay people are just as law-abiding as straight people.Now, what my neighbour does affects me, right? Good or bad. Why should I suffer for my neighbours sin ? If I am going to suffer for my neighbours sin, you can bet I will go after his hide. Yes, I do care if my neighbour is a gay or a terrorist or a child molester or anything that acts against the good of society.
Agree. Gods laws have never changed - there never were any, so why change that. What reason is there for these laws?[/quote]Really? Times have changed, so Gods rules changed too? Can you drink blood ? Can you eat animal fat ? Can you rape ? Can you take another mans wife ? Can a father sleep with his daughter ? Can you sleep with your mother? b/c times have changed and rules change along with time? The answer will show you that Gods Laws are perpetual. Immutable, unchangeable.
You contradict yourself when you say Gods laws have never changed and then you turn around and say there never were any. [/quote]
This is not a contradiction. If God never had laws, and there still are none, his laws have not changed.
I agree that humans are here to experiences being with god. But what I don't get is that we need rules to do so. Rules allow us to stop thinking for ourselves - it's just so much easier to obey. True free will would let us do whatever we wished and there being no retributions from god. No rules is what people are afraid of. This means that they have to look at every situation and think for themselves, rather than blindly following orders and rules.The reason for these Laws?
The human specie is created to live with Father God in heaven. Sin caused the Law to be given in black and white. The Law, therefore, divides righteousness from sin in a clear cut way. God is systematic and orderly. Satan has no-system. Disobedience to the Law, automatically by default, places a person in the dark kingdom.
A parent does not care one way or another what his/her children do to play. Is it a matter of consquence whether they play tag, hide-and-seek or pretend? No, because you know you have placed the child in a safe environment. Would god put us in an "unsafe" environment? No. Not for spiritual advancement - only physical. But what does the physical side matter if you have 2nd, 3rd, or even 86th chances?
Ye are Gods
Post #52
First, we must know who gave us the bible. Would God lie ? Would a prophet lie and say something else that God didnt say ? Isaiah, Jeremiah, Moses, Based on these questions, I take the bible as Gods Word b/c God claims it as His word. I believe God. God would not allow lies into His Holy Book. That is why only certain versions of the Bible are reliable.methylatedghosts wrote: I have read the bible, and found for myself, that although some things in it may have happened, it isn't all truth as far as I can see.
Where in the bible isn't all truth as far as I can see ? Let me know.
Equality for women, this I understand. Homosexuals would be better off doing their own thing than to demand legal rights. From the beginning of time till now, no govt. has been so openly audacious against God. This to me, is not an issue of equality but a challenge to Gods Law. You see it as equal rights I see it as challenging Gods Law. Being lawless, to me, is a backward step.methylatedghosts wrote: How in the world is allowing equality for all people, regardless of sexual orientation backwards?
It is interesting that you equate yourself to an animal. It is needless to argue that if animals can do it, so can the human specie. Why dont you compare yourself with angels instead ? Man is made in the image of God, animals are not. You testify to the truth in scripture that says we must focus on the high spiritual things of God. Otherwise, the mind tends to go downwards, into darkness.methylatedghosts wrote: You DO see some species doing homosexual activities though, so why is it so unnatural for humans?
As I said, homosexuals should just do their own thing instead of clamouring for legal rights. Legalising gay marriage impacts the country. Agriculture suffer when there is no rain, for example, I will just have to wait and see what God will do to your country. Yes, gay people are just like us, law-abiding folks except that they bring an abominable law into existence to magnify this sin that will destroy society.methylatedghosts wrote: I still don't see how your neighbour being gay can affect you in any way. Just because he or she is gay doesn't mean he's out to target you. How will YOU suffer for it? Someone being gay is not against the "good of society". Gay people are just as law-abiding as straight people.
If God never had laws then there is no law to change NOT his laws have not changed meaning there are laws but these have not changed. I thought english is your mother-tongue.methylatedghosts wrote: This is not a contradiction. If God never had laws, and there still are none, his laws have not changed.
Let me see you give your child true free will to do w/ever he please and bear no retributions from you when he plays with fire that will burn the house and neighbouring houses into ashes. With true free will, let your child rape you and steal from you and does w/ever he wants with you. I dont think you know what youre saying.methylatedghosts wrote: True free will would let us do whatever we wished and there being no retributions from god.
Dont tell me you do not have a child. This is a hypothetical scenario based on your words.
Post #53
Perhaps a few lessons in logic would help you understand what a circular argument is.topaz wrote:I take the bible as Gods Word b/c God claims it as His word.
Where does god claim it is his word - in the bible of course.
Talking snakes. men living in fish, the dead rising up...to name a few.topaz wrote:
Where in the bible isn't all truth as far as I can see ? Let me know.
methylatedghosts wrote: How in the world is allowing equality for all people, regardless of sexual orientation backwards?
I see it as religious bigotry and prejudice.topaz wrote: I see it as challenging Gods Law...
Why? We are animals - part of the biosphere. If we understood this we would not be in the environmental mess we are in today.topaz wrote: It is interesting that you equate yourself to an animal.
Because they don't exist. It would be the same as comparing myself with Santa.topaz wrote: Why dont you compare yourself with angels instead ?
I thought "All men are equal under god" actually meant something.topaz wrote: As I said, homosexuals should just do their own thing instead of clamouring for legal rights.
Huh? What a glorious non-sequitor.topaz wrote: Legalising gay marriage impacts the country. Agriculture suffer when there is no rain, for example,...
More pots and kettles here than a hotel kitchen.topaz wrote: I dont think you know what youre saying.
"Whatever you are totally ignorant of, assert to be the explanation of everything else"
William James quoting Dr. Hodgson
"When I see I am nothing, that is wisdom. When I see I am everything, that is love. My life is a movement between these two."
Nisargadatta Maharaj
William James quoting Dr. Hodgson
"When I see I am nothing, that is wisdom. When I see I am everything, that is love. My life is a movement between these two."
Nisargadatta Maharaj
- Madeline
- Apprentice
- Posts: 221
- Joined: Sun Oct 15, 2006 3:57 am
- Location: U.S. (From Cheshire, England)
Post #54
What does the bible say? God says that fags will not inherit the Kingdom of God! So how can a gay person be a Christian? they can't!
Know ye not that the unrighteous shall not inherit the kingdom of God? Be not deceived: neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor effeminate (HOMOSEXUALS), nor abusers of themselves with mankind, Nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners, shall inherit the kingdom of God. [1 Corinthians 6:9,10]
Love,
Madeline
Know ye not that the unrighteous shall not inherit the kingdom of God? Be not deceived: neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor effeminate (HOMOSEXUALS), nor abusers of themselves with mankind, Nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners, shall inherit the kingdom of God. [1 Corinthians 6:9,10]
Love,
Madeline
- methylatedghosts
- Sage
- Posts: 516
- Joined: Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:21 pm
- Location: Dunedin, New Zealand
Post #55
Philosophers and historians.topaz wrote:First, we must know who gave us the bible.
No.Would God lie ?
[quoteWould a prophet lie and say something else that God didnt say ?[/quote]
That's assuming god said something to him. But then, probably not. BUT translations and retellings change the original message.
Where in the bible isn't all truth as far as I can see ? Let me know.[/quote]
Adding to what bernee said: hares, according to bible, are ruminants/chew their cud. Anyway, wrong thread for this.... lets move this to the "Is the bible a work of god" thread.
It is interesting that you equate yourself to an animal. It is needless to argue that if animals can do it, so can the human specie. Why dont you compare yourself with angels instead ? Man is made in the image of God, animals are not. You testify to the truth in scripture that says we must focus on the high spiritual things of God. Otherwise, the mind tends to go downwards, into darkness.I compare not only myself, but you also as with everyone to animals, because we all evolved from pretty much the same thing, and we are classified as part of the primate family. Take bonobo(sp?) monkeys. They are genetically very close to humans. They have ALOT of sex - including gay sex, and they hardly fight, like chimpanzees do.
As I said, homosexuals should just do their own thing instead of clamouring for legal rights. Legalising gay marriage impacts the country. Agriculture suffer when there is no rain, for example, I will just have to wait and see what God will do to your country. Yes, gay people are just like us, law-abiding folks except that they bring an abominable law into existence to magnify this sin that will destroy society.
You know what I mean.If God never had laws then there is no law to change NOT his laws have not changed meaning there are laws but these have not changed. I thought english is your mother-tongue.
I said "A parent does not care one way or another what his/her children do to play. Is it a matter of consquence whether they play tag, hide-and-seek or pretend? No, because you know you have placed the child in a safe environment. Would god put us in an "unsafe" environment?"Let me see you give your child true free will to do w/ever he please and bear no retributions from you when he plays with fire that will burn the house and neighbouring houses into ashes. With true free will, let your child rape you and steal from you and does w/ever he wants with you. I dont think you know what youre saying.
Dont tell me you do not have a child. This is a hypothetical scenario based on your words.
I'm not talking about fire and burning down houses. Then the child was not put in a safe environment. I don't think you know what I'm saying.
I am linking this to god putting us in a safe environment. You should read more carefully. (not saying that I don't need to before you retort)
Ye are Gods
Post #56
You forgot, a talking donkey balaam. So you think all these are lies, illogical ? God being God, can do anything. Is this also illogical ? When you speak to your pet dog and he understands you .. is this illogical ?bernee51 wrote:Perhaps a few lessons in logic would help you understand what a circular argument is.topaz wrote:I take the bible as Gods Word b/c God claims it as His word.
Where does god claim it is his word - in the bible of course.Talking snakes. men living in fish, the dead rising up...to name a few.topaz wrote:
Where in the bible isn't all truth as far as I can see ? Let me know.
I believe that animals can speak our language if God wants it so. I believe Jonah was in the whale for 3 days and 3 nights and didnt suffocate to death in there. Yes, I also believe in all the miracles of Jesus Christ of Nazareth.
Ive seen a big miracle in my life and people with such mental limitations as yourself couldnt influence me one iota. Youre the one who is illogical, bernee.
It is foolish to challenge when you know you cannot win. How can man make a law that is biblically unlawful in the first place ? You cannot win this war against God. You are backward when you align yourself with the dark forces. Satan is dead meat. I wonder how on earth some people can still be on his side.bernee51 wrote:methylatedghosts wrote: How in the world is allowing equality for all people, regardless of sexual orientation backwards?I see it as religious bigotry and prejudice.topaz wrote: I see it as challenging Gods Law...
Youre delusional. Poor thing.bernee51 wrote:Because they don't exist. It would be the same as comparing myself with Santa.topaz wrote: Why dont you compare yourself with angels instead ?
You poor soul, youre so confused about everything. I dont know where to start.bernee51 wrote:I thought "All men are equal under god" actually meant something.topaz wrote: As I said, homosexuals should just do their own thing instead of clamouring for legal rights.
Yes, what sin does is it desolates the land. My example no rain everybody is affected. Passing a law which is unlawful will only make Gods judgement more fiery. Youre inviting it. Woe.bernee51 wrote:Huh? What a glorious non-sequitor.topaz wrote: Legalising gay marriage impacts the country. Agriculture suffer when there is no rain, for example,...
Indeed bernee, you too dont know what youre saying. How can you align yourself with satan and say we seek God just as you do .. ? If you really seek God, then why are you challenging Him by claiming what is wrong to be right ? Youre playing semantics. This will not help you in your hour of need. Look at whats happening around in Asia. Tsunami, earthquake after earthquake, hurricanes, mud flood till it covers the rooftop, it is really scary God help you if you truly dont understand.bernee51 wrote:More pots and kettles here than a hotel kitchen.topaz wrote: I dont think you know what youre saying.
- methylatedghosts
- Sage
- Posts: 516
- Joined: Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:21 pm
- Location: Dunedin, New Zealand
Post #57
Talking to a dog and it understanding IS logical (if it's commands we're talking about) dogs learn that after much training, sit means sit. stay means stay. But it can't understand human language in conversation.topaz wrote:You forgot, a talking donkey balaam. So you think all these are lies, illogical ? God being God, can do anything. Is this also illogical ? When you speak to your pet dog and he understands you .. is this illogical ?
How in the world did Jonah not get killed by all the stomach acids - let alone drown in them? Impossible, illogical.I believe that animals can speak our language if God wants it so. I believe Jonah was in the whale for 3 days and 3 nights and didnt suffocate to death in there. Yes, I also believe in all the miracles of Jesus Christ of Nazareth.
What miracle was this? (honestly, I'm just curious)Ive seen a big miracle in my life and people with such mental limitations as yourself couldnt influence me one iota. Youre the one who is illogical, bernee.
Ummmm, by putting it in our law.....It is foolish to challenge when you know you cannot win. How can man make a law that is biblically unlawful in the first place ?
It isn't about winning or losing. It isn't about who's right and who's wrong. It is about learning who you are in relation to everything else. It is taking what others say and working out for yourself whether or not it is true, not what a book or a guy in robes says
There is no war between god and I. secondly, there is no such thing as satan. This is only a mythology created to describe the creation of relativity.You cannot win this war against God. You are backward when you align yourself with the dark forces. Satan is dead meat. I wonder how on earth some people can still be on his side.
Yet, here you are believing in a "wrathful, loving god". THAT doesn't make a lick of sense.Youre delusional. Poor thing.bernee51 wrote:Because they don't exist. It would be the same as comparing myself with Santa.topaz wrote: Why dont you compare yourself with angels instead ?
Who's to say you aren't? He doesn't seem confused to me at all, he seems to know exactly what he's talking about. You, however come across as confused in relation to this above quote.You poor soul, youre so confused about everything. I dont know where to start.bernee51 wrote:I thought "All men are equal under god" actually meant something.topaz wrote: As I said, homosexuals should just do their own thing instead of clamouring for legal rights.
How can legalising gay marriage "desolate the land? Please explain how and why and what the result will be.Yes, what sin does is it desolates the land. My example no rain everybody is affected. Passing a law which is unlawful will only make Gods judgement more fiery. Youre inviting it. Woe.bernee51 wrote:Huh? What a glorious non-sequitor.topaz wrote: Legalising gay marriage impacts the country. Agriculture suffer when there is no rain, for example,...
Earthquakes are not caused by god or satan. It is the shifting tectonic plates. Tunamis are caused by the earthquakes. Hurricanes are only very low pressure systems. A mud flood is caused by too much water added to the soil.Indeed bernee, you too dont know what youre saying. How can you align yourself with satan and say we seek God just as you do .. ? If you really seek God, then why are you challenging Him by claiming what is wrong to be right ? Youre playing semantics. This will not help you in your hour of need. Look at whats happening around in Asia. Tsunami, earthquake after earthquake, hurricanes, mud flood till it covers the rooftop, it is really scary God help you if you truly dont understand.
Ye are Gods
Post #58
Ah the wonderful "god works in myserious ways" cop out. I was expecting that from you sooner.topaz wrote: You forgot, a talking donkey balaam. So you think all these are lies, illogical ? God being God, can do anything.
Yestopaz wrote: Is this also illogical ?
Ever heard of Pavlov? My dog does not 'undertand' me. It knows that when a bell rings he gets fed.topaz wrote: When you speak to your pet dog and he understands you .. is this illogical ?
Besides this is a straw man argument. My dog does not talk back to me and advise mt wo eat the fruit from a particular tree.
But not in unicorns, the easter bunny or santa? Why not?topaz wrote: I believe that animals can speak our language if God wants it so. I believe Jonah was in the whale for 3 days and 3 nights and didnt suffocate to death in there. Yes, I also believe in all the miracles of Jesus Christ of Nazareth.
topaz wrote: Ive seen a big miracle in my life...{/quote]
I see a miracle in my life every day
Ad hominems don't win arguments - the only demonstrate the paucity of yours.topaz wrote: and people with such mental limitations as yourself couldnt influence me one iota.
You sayiong so doens't make it so. In order to do that you have to use logic to show mine to be suspect. You have not done that. Al you have done is attack me personally. Calling me illogical or mentally limited is a cop out.topaz wrote: Youre the one who is illogical, bernee.
It is one often used by self proclaimed "true christians"(tm) such as yourself.
Without challenge there is no growth. You should try it sometime.topaz wrote: It is foolish to challenge when you know you cannot win.
I am not out to 'win'. I could care less that you believe the illogical. If it provides meaning and purpose in you liffe that is wonderful for you. That is the function of the translative religion you have attached yourself to.
I am not at war with your god. How can I be at war with a non-existent entity?topaz wrote: How can man make a law that is biblically unlawful in the first place ? You cannot win this war against God.
You saying so doesn't make it so.topaz wrote: Youre delusional. Poor thing.
Use some logic to prove it
Really - how so?topaz wrote: You poor soul, youre so confused about everything.
And you call me confused. I am the one providing the argument - all you can say is "you're confused, your edelusional, you're illogical"topaz wrote: I dont know where to start.
Ad hominems with no meat.
"Whatever you are totally ignorant of, assert to be the explanation of everything else"
William James quoting Dr. Hodgson
"When I see I am nothing, that is wisdom. When I see I am everything, that is love. My life is a movement between these two."
Nisargadatta Maharaj
William James quoting Dr. Hodgson
"When I see I am nothing, that is wisdom. When I see I am everything, that is love. My life is a movement between these two."
Nisargadatta Maharaj
Post #59
Hi meth
You talk of relativity, Einstein. Do you know that Einstein was a christian. Yes a messianic christian. How about that ?
So please don't give me all that crap explanation about tsunami, earthquake and all. God is bigger and deeper than science.
And ... don't you know that the bible says sin desolates the land ?
You talk of relativity, Einstein. Do you know that Einstein was a christian. Yes a messianic christian. How about that ?
So please don't give me all that crap explanation about tsunami, earthquake and all. God is bigger and deeper than science.
And ... don't you know that the bible says sin desolates the land ?
- McCulloch
- Site Supporter
- Posts: 24063
- Joined: Mon May 02, 2005 9:10 pm
- Location: Toronto, ON, CA
- Been thanked: 3 times
Post #60
Topaz, this one is news to me. Can you provide any supporting evidence to your claim that Albert Einstein, winner of the 1921 Nobel prize, who raised funds for Hebrew University of Jerusalem and who was offered the post of president of the Israeli government in 1952 was a Christian? Please do cite your references, there are quite a number of well researched biographies of this man.topaz wrote:You talk of relativity, Einstein. Do you know that Einstein was a christian. Yes a messianic christian. How about that ?
Examine everything carefully; hold fast to that which is good.
First Epistle to the Church of the Thessalonians
The truth will make you free.
Gospel of John
First Epistle to the Church of the Thessalonians
The truth will make you free.
Gospel of John

